Customer Reviews Trotters Samantha

I have painful arthritis in my big toe, and it is tough to fit into a dress shoe. I bought these because of the elastic band, hoping that would help. Unfortunately, there is little to no stretch in this band. I’m not sure why they say it is elastic.

They are quite heavy. The heel was much too wide.Front part of the shoe fit just fine.

Started off very comfortable. The heel is very stiff. Only have worn one day - couldn’t wear after lunch. Both feet had blisters

Me: Size 11+, but I am stuck in a size 11 since 12's are too big, wide ball of foot, bunions and narrow heel. I wanted to love these, but they are kinda old lady-ish, and I am 73. The throat of the shoe was too high on the top of my foot to be really comfortable, and the length was too short. Other than that, just perfect! :-)

Only wore them once. Beautiful shoes. I reordered them a half size smaller. May even have to go a full size shorter. I'll see when they arrive. Too bad one wearing makes them non-returnable.

The shoes were very cute, seemed to be very nicely made and looked as though it would be comfortable; however, we could not even get it on my grandmother's foot (it was too small) and she has been a 7.5N all her life ... she's 96!

I have a narrow foot. The size was good, but they were too wide and would not stay on my foot. Very disappointed they did not work out.

I had ordered the 8.5 WW and I walked right out of this shoe. The blue suede is gorgeous. I wish it had fit. sending back.

heel too narrow for my foot

Uneven fit between left and right foot. I normally buy 8.5 W or 9. I bought 9W in this one because I sensed that 8.5W wont work. I tried these on and the right shoe kept coming off at the heel as I walked. The right one was perfect! Will have to return it!

my heel slipped up and down

These shoes were long enough, but they were too narrow in the widest part of the toe box. First time trying them on, they were squeezing my foot (and I don't have a weird foot or bunions or anything.) I briefly thought, "Well, maybe they'll stretch out," and then I thought, for the money, I don't want to have to make accommodations. Unfortunately, of my whole order, this pair was the reason I went shopping in the first place. Back they go, and back to the drawing board I go - for black patent leather flats. It shouldn't be this difficult...

I ordered a wide. They were too wide. And, even though they were too wide, they hurt my left foot. The style is cute, I wish they fit. But did not fit and even hurt my foot!

The heels were a little big and my feet could not stay in the shoe.

Again - as with the aerosoles, these shoes were much wider than the Trotters I bought 2 years ago. Does everyone have fat feet these days? Had to return because I couldn't keep them on my feet while walking.

They are a bit loose so I feel like my feet are swimming in them just enough to be annoying but not enough to use an insert.

I have a very narrow size 11 foot. The heel of this shoe is too loose and I walk right out of the shoe. They were snug around the toe area but too loose in the back. Very fancy looking flat. Would be great for a dressy event.

The toes of the shoes are SQUARISH!! I prefer a rounded toe-I could see the possibility of stumbling with the square toe look! Am sending the shoes back.

Too narrow, painful on my heel

I love the Trotters brand, and have never had an issue with them, until this pair. I have hard-to-fit narrow feet, usually because the shoes are not narrow enough. This pair, however was SO NARROW, that I could not even get my foot into them. Yes, I chose "Felt true to size", as they appeared long enough, but, way too tight width wise. Even the top of the shoe that goes over the toes was extremely tight. Rats! They are very pretty, but not for me.

These shoes were so cute that I wanted them to fit, but when I replaced the removable footbed with my orthotics, they were too tight, mostly in the height.

I wear 8 or 8 1/2 and the 8 1/2 did not fit well in some spots. The band rubbed the top of my foot and I ended up with a blister on my heel - both unusual for me with an 8 1/2, so I returned the item. They did seem very supportive and would have otherwise been comfortable. Note that the accents are iridescent, which I didn't expect. It made them appear cheaper and/or an older style.

I can't keep ballet slippers on my feet, but I thought the elastic would make these work for me. It didn't. Too bad. These are really cute shoes.

These shoes run wide. The style is very pretty on, however, when I walked they slipped off the back of my heel.

I liked the shoe overall in terms of the style and look. But my feet said no. The decorative strap crosses over my bunion surgery areas and they were not impressed.