Customer Reviews Trotters Doris

I loved these shoes when they arrived. They were exactly the look that I wanted, and I wore them around the house and they seemed to fit okay. Then I wore them for the first time, to a business meeting in another city, and I was mortified to find that walking around on city streets (faster than I had walk around my house), the shoes were unwearable. As in literally, they would not stay on my feet. I found myself doing a weird limp trying to keep up with my coworkers, and even so the shoes pretty much came off my feet several times mid-stride. I can only assume that the problem here is that I had to buy the wide width because the front of my foot is too wide for the regular width, but my heel is too narrow to work with the rest of the shoe. My heel slipped so badly out of the shoes and there was not enough material up front to keep them attached to the rest of my foot. They had to go in the trash when I got home. I am really bummed because I loved how they look (and I wasted money) but I could not ever wear them again.

Thought the fabric would give enough to allow for the huge bunion, but it just was not wide enough so had to return these.

These shoes were not wide enough for me so my feet couldn't fit in at all. My feet are WW so I got Trotters Dora instead. They fit well and are comfortable.

I bought a 9W the first time (Trotters) and they were so big I ordered a 9 M. I could barely get my foot in. I chose to go to another brand in a 3rd size

I returned these because they were not a true wide shoe. Sorry Trotters. I guess I'll keep looking. Thanks Zappos.

The shoes are stylish, but they are not what they used to be. This is the third time I order this pair of shoes. I loved the previous two pairs, and received a lot of compliments. Now the quality has dropped dramatically. The black leather shoes aren't even black. They look almost navy blue. The leather is not shiny, it is opaque and not as soft. Also, they are not as comfortable as they used to be. I sent them back.

Very disappointed! I ordered this shoe in 3 different sizes and none of them fit. The 11.5 double wide was too big. The 11.5 wide and 11 wide wide were too tight. It is so hard to find comfortable shoes.

I wore this shoes once for the day and it becomes very sloppy. I was not able to return. Most likely will not by shoes from them again!

Great shoe, comfortable, good solid work shoe, LOVE it, but the heel caps have fallen out twice in less than a month. I shouldn't be having to repair brand new shoes. :(

Sorry, they just do not fit--too tight and uncomfortable.

I was shocked at how short and tight these shoes are in the toes. I'm a straight-up 7N and I could barely squeeze my toes in. I almost wondered if the shoes were mis-sized.

I was very hopeful that these shoes would be a good option for business dress, however they absolutely killed my feet. Blisters, bandaids, pressure in the wrong places and I was a mess. I did wear this at home for hours and days before I attempted to wear to a work function, and they seemed fine, but in the real world, they squeezed my toes and rubbed them raw. I don't recommend Trotters shoes.

So uncomfortable...and I wore them for the day so I have to keep them. Tight toe box and they run small...I had a huge blister by the end of the day.

I have navy Trotters Doris that were made in Brazil and they felt wonderful from the first day I put them on. These are too tight in the toe area and too stiff. They are not made in Brazil.

I have worn Trotters for years because they fit well and are usually very comfortable. However, I recently purchased another pair of navy "Doris" and they did not fit the same as before. One shoe was alright, but the other was so wide that it gaped all the way down the inside of my right foot. The quality did not appear to be nearly as nice as my other Trotters. In the past, their sizing and quality were consistent, but now they appear to have serious quality control issues. The shoes were made in China so I suspect this is a major reason for the overall decline. Too bad because Trotters always made good quality comfortable shoes in the past.

These shoes had no structure, and rippled around my feet.

Wildly inconsistent sizing I so wanted to have this shoe! I just don't think it's going to happen. I ordered the mocha in a size 10.5 medium. These should have fit me like a dream. Alas, the shoe was tight. Very tight. I thought that perhaps I was sent a Narrow instead of a Medium, but the shoe was indeed a 10.5 Medium. I then ordered the size 11, same color, half a size up, same width. They arrived today and I am SWIMMING in them! They are WAY longer and WAY wider than the first pair I ordered. They are also a few shades of brown lighter. I loved the color of the first shoe, which was a very deep, rich brown. There is no way a half size up in the same width should have this much discrepancy. I'm so disappointed as they will both have to be returned. Thank goodness Zappos makes returns easy, but the sizing (and color) issue of this shoe is really galling.