Customer Reviews Naturalizer SOUL Naturalizer - Cindi

I bought four similar-looking black strappy sandals (the Dr. Scholl’s Golden Hour, the Naturalizer SOUL Cindi, the LifeStride Zoom, and the SOREL Ella III Sandal), all in my regular size 8.5, and felt the Naturalizer SOUL Cindi was the best fit for me. They are by far the most comfortable of the four, have a slight heel, and can be dressed up or down. The Dr. Scholl’s Golden Hour was my second choice but was physically heavier and looked heavier due to the black sole. I felt the LifeStride Zoom was rigid and uncomfortable, and the SOREL Ella III was fine but I preferred the Naturalizer Cindi over it (and for $25 less).

I am a flip flop girl for summer but I am having back issues and my doctor said “no flip flops!” OMG! I ordered several pairs of leather sandals that I thought looked fashionable. The Nauturalizer Soul were the only ones that had stability that were comfy. The shoe has amazing arch support and is easy to put on even with a bad back. The only issue I have with them is the zipper in the back. There is a flap of leather to protect your heel, which is good but at first it is hard to keep the leather out of the way while zipping the shoe. Enter my wonderful husband of over 50 years. He can zip them right up and now they are getting more pliable so I can too. They are very comfortable. I was worried about the strap placement with my little toes but it works fine. Love these sandals if I have to give up my flip flops for a while.

These worked for me. Lesson learned, there is a variance in size for difference manufacturers. I love these and this pair fits perfect!

Love these! Very comfortable, true to size. Comfortable from the get-go.

Great sandal and very comfortable. Would buy again.

Stylish and comfortable sandal. Looking forward to wearing them on an upcoming vacation.

I loved this style and wanted it to be right for me - but the outside middle of my foot was rubbing on the edge of the sandal. Wore it on carpet and just didn't feel it would work in a normal day of wearing for me.

Love these sandals. Very comfortable and stylish.

My feet are true wide widths and these fit very well and are comfortable! The brown color is lovely and will pair nicely with various clothing items. The zipper feature is nice for sliding feet right in. Cannot wait to wear them regularly for the summer.

Really cute, better looking in person, the leather is soft, the footbed is soft and has a slight slant, cork heal, really cute, but I was unable to zip up the back heal. I will have to return.

I really like these sandals. comfy with support

Made for thicker ankles, or just thicker feet than mine, so the front cross strap was too far away from my foot and the shoe didn’t fit tight enough to not be flippy floppy.

Cute, but feet feel very unsupported

These are cute, felt comfortable when I first put them on, then as I walked around I realized they rub me on my Achilles tendon and somewhat across the underside of my big toe. I am returning them.

This is a very attractive sandal! Even though it isn't real leather, it looks and feels lsoft and pliable! The loved the style, but there isn't much arch support and the only reason I am returning is, it pinches both little toes a bit and am worried that wearing for any length of time will irritate! I have a wide foot, so that is where the problem lies...try them, they are very cute!

Heel was too wide for me.

I am sometimes an 8 and sometimes an 8.5 in shoes and the 8 was a good fit for me. These are comfortable but the straps aren’t that fitted as I would like.