Customer Reviews Jack Rogers Georgica Jelly

These are super cute, but very very flat and a little slippery to walk in. I get compliments whenever I wear them!

Love these! However, ironically, I bought them thinking that because they are rubber, they'd be great in wet weather, but in the rain, the tops get so slick that they fly off your feet! On the dry days they are comfortable and good looking.

I had always wanted a pair of Jack Rogers but thought the emblem on the heel would hurt and viola! found this pair with no engraving on the sole. They are the most comfortable jelly sandal I have found! Easy to clean and cute. I wear a 9.5, it said to order a half size down so I got the 9 which feels a little small but wearable. The blue color is a light aqua, goes with a lot of summer colors!

If you are looking for jelly shoes, these are great! They would an excellent substitute for flip flops at the beach. I returned them because I wasn't wild about how big the medallion on the top of my foot was. I was looking for something dresser.

These look great but I’ve slipped every single time I wear them. No traction whatsoever. If you can remember to walk slow and avoid slippery surfaces you’ll be fine but definitely not recommended for pool days or chasing kiddos.

These are very cute and felt ok on my foot but they looked too short and too narrow. Also I could easily see them rubbing blisters between my toes if I walked in them for more than a walk to the pool and back. Ultimately decided they weren’t worth the price and returned them.

Loved the shoe ordered it in May and it just broke a week ago after light wear... I guess unhappy with the quality! That's why 3 stars

Love the ideas of these shoes. The big round part of them digs into one of the bones in the top of my foot making these so painful to wear. Maybe I just need to break them in a little more.

Bought these to replace a pair of Tory Butch Miller sandals that broke. While these seem like they will last longer.. they aren't the comfiest shoes out there. Super cute, but i wouldn't wear them all day to shop!

These are cute and waterproof. They are uncomfortable. They have a small and narrow footbed. The straps are way too loose. They only come in half sizes. They are also expensive for the quality.

Jack Rogers sizing seems to get a bit weird at larger sizes (I'm an 11). This shoe is fun for what it is, and I'll wear it because I'm out of time for getting something else. The sandal is both a bit long and a bit narrow, and the toe-strap is placed oddly in relation to the side straps.

I had purchased a pair of the black/white Jellies and love them. Unfortunately, the color of these Silver/Gold ones is not accurate. They look much whiter in the picture and in person they look like a dirty gray, and the gold looks like a dirty yellow. I will be returning these.

These do not look gold at all. They are also very loose around the foot. They feel larger then a size 8.

Beautiful but absolutely painful if you need any kind of arch support. These are as flat as pancakes and I can't imagine walking anywhere in these shoes.

I love the way these shoes look. Much better than flip flops. My problem is that the seams of the rubber are on each side of the thong. They were very uncomfortable for me. Not like the leather thong at all.

I have a leather pair of Georgica sandals and they fit perfectly but the jelly style's foot bed is too long. It shows quite a bit of sandal beyond your toes and when they are bright white like these it is very noticeable. Have to return these.

The shoe is really cute, but I had to return them because the toe area had way too much room, and the heel didn't leave enough room. So I ordered a size 8, which I am in just about every other shoe, but in the Jack Rogers Georgia sandal, my heel was falling off the back, yet I had excess room in the toe area, and I don't think I have short toes. These didn't fit so well in my regular size, but I fear that if I go to a size 9, that will just leave that much more room in the toe, making it look ill-fitting, but maybe worth a slot because this is a cute shoe - a great alternative to the over-logo-emblazoned Tory Burch sandals.

Cute but so uncomfortable I had to return

I really wanted to like these. They were just too narrow to be practical.

It must be a Jack Rogers thing. These sandals hurt. There is zero support. Just hard jelly plastic that does not give. I had to buy stick on insoles to wear to my family reunion. That only worked for about 2 hours. The jelly is hard. No squish in traditional jelly's Super good looking shoe. But not a shoe to walk in for a day in Miami. Painful feet. Painful low back. I buy flats instead of heels to enjoy comfort. With these, stilettos are more comfortable to walk in.