Customer Reviews Clarks Carleigh Jane

GOOD quality shoe, comfortable and I liked how it looked on. However, I have narrow feet and the toe area was too wide even in the Narrow size for me.

I thought I would try something other than a tie shoe which is what I am always forced to buy. This shoe was a little too long and too large, not good for my narrow flat foot. I wear a size 12 N. The leather is solid, not too soft, which I like, and the workmanship seems well done. Over all my foot floated in this shoe, so it was too roomy for me. I have a flat foot, no arch. There was a big gap between the top of my foot and the strap, therefore the strap did not hold and secure my foot or offer any support which I desperately need. I hoped things would work out but a foot like mine needs a tie shoe to be secure.

Loved these shoes. But single strap is fixed in place: no way to tighten, so too loose for my very narrow feet.

I fluctuate between a 10 and 11 wide (D/E). They fit ok, but I wish I had gotten the 11 as my long toe seems to just hit the tip of the shoe. If I walked more, I’d get the size up.

Oh how I love these shoes. BUT.....I already had a pair and the button on on one of the shoes came loose and got lost, so I decided to order a second pair, but after thinking about it and the expense, I sent them back and decided to rehabilitate my ones with the missing button. These are comfortable shoes to last.

Cute shoe but the strap is pointless for me. I have a large gap. I will be returning.

I'm 99% of the time a women's size 8. I read all of the reviews on these which said they were very wide but pretty much true to size. A few reviews said they had to be returned because they were so wide. I don't have narrow feet so that didn't deter me, just ordered my normal size, normal width. The size 8s were very snug and not wide at all for me. They felt almost claustrophobic. I returned for 8 1/2s and they are perfect.

This is a wonderfully comfortable shoe for me. I have a high instep and need a wide width. It is so comfortable that this is the third pair I have purchased in the past few months. One pair for every day wear, one pair for if we are going out and the third pair in reserve for when the first pair wears out. The leather is nice and thick, the buttons are metal and tied on with a very sturdy strap and when I was doing a lot of work on the ground for many days one of the buttons came off. Not an issue as I could easily slide it back on and tie. Good as new. I am hard on shoes and these are holding up very well. Easy to slip on and off, but never loose. My orthotics fit just fine and I hope this style hangs around for a long time. On a scale of one to 10, they are certainly a 10.

Way to wide for me

A very good shoe and looked great. The problem was after a week it didn't fit anymore

Really liked the shoe, but just started wearing recently. after only 5 uses the stitching stanted coming out where shoe meets the strap.

the strap across the top is too slow

Disappointed. Shoe felt great, good arch support, large enough box. But strap is too long and cannot be adjusted. Created a half inch space between foot and strap.

This shoe was cute and relatively wide, but it didn't feel like it would be comfortable without socks, and I was hoping that I could wear it without needing socks.

Way to wide