Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Colin

Beautiful-looking shoe; however, it is stiff. Also I'm usually a size 6.5 or 7. I ordered a 6.5 and it kept falling off my heel so I ordered a size 6. Same thing. Sadly, I had to return this beautiful shoe.

These shoes are beautiful. I bought them because they looked pretty and I thought they would be comfortable to wear to work. I am a hairstylist ad stand on my feet all day. I've worn them 3 times hoping they would break in and each time I couldn't wait to get home to take them off because they hurt so badly. It's very disappointing as I have many pairs of Sam Edelman shoes due to their design and comfort level.

The shoes are beautiful but don't fit. I have many pairs of SE shoes, all size nine. These are too big.

Beautiful style, well crafted, but don't come in a narrow width. I love these and I want to keep them, but I can't keep them on my feet. I have tried sizing down, inserts of every shape and size, socks, etc., and I still walk right out of them. Hi regret that they must go back.

These are sharp looking loafers. Unfortunately, they are not leather on the body of the shoe, and the vinyl was not forgiving enough for the top of my foot, so it irritated the top of my foot and gave me a bruise.

Very narrow. I was hoping to add these to my work shoes collection but they are much too narrow for an average foot. I really love the metal embellishment on the right shoe. They are a stiff feel when you walk and there is no in sole padding. Just not for me

These shoes are so very well made and have an air of elegance- the packaging is even beautiful and unwrapping it is almost an experience. The leather is buttery soft and the stitching is flawless. It had really wonderful cushioning and seemed to have great arch support. I think it would be so comfortable if it were the right size for my hobbit feet. I am usually a 8 1/2 or 9; however, these size 9 were much too small for me and cut into my ankle. However, when I used the suggested sizing chart after, my measurements would have been size 9. I also have very flat feet but sometimes wide shoes cause my feet to slip around making them terribly uncomfortable- if you are in the fence-order wide- I made the mistake of ordering medium and my feet were VERY squished. I wish there were some guidance on the size chart to measure width. Not sure I'm a fan of this particular style- the buckle placement and tongue placement seemed a little too pilgrim-y. I also think thick black sole make the shoe look too chunky for me. But I think it would work with the right outfit! Love that there is just the right amount of gold detailing to add class without making it feel gaudy. Love the quality- wish I had been more careful with the sizing.

The most beautiful white loafers but too narrow and stiff and made funny noises when i try on my feet, sadly I returned them. I m size 6.5 and i bougth 5.5 because the reviews and 5.5 fits rigth but too tigth

I brought these a few weeks ago and I am not that happy with them They wing out on the sides, they are not true to side for the slim feet person. I got 8.5 my original shoe size. They are slipping off my feet. And I purchased two pair ream and black.

These loafers stretched out with minimal wear, to the point that they are now unusable. In the past, I have worn the same size in Sam Edelman shoes and have had several pairs of various shoes over the years. Never had this issue until now. Unfortunately, the Colin loafers seemed to fit initially, but after 2 full days of use, they stretched and my feet slid out of the loafer while walking. I almost sprained my ankle! Do not recommend for this reason. Wish I could return.

I love the finish--kinda like tortoise shell. Beautiful! Unfortunately, they were very uncomfortable. I sized up as suggested. Even with that, they were uncomfortably tight across the bridge of my foot.

Look great. But every step I take, the shoes keep coming off the heels. And I don't even have narrow feet. Not wearable.

I bought a patent leather style. Already splitting and cracking. Disappointing to say the least.