Customer Reviews Madewell Whisper Cotton Scoopneck Tank Top

I wasn’t overly impressed with this shirt. The fabric is thin and it’s really long which is a departure from most of my tops. Still it’s good for a casual around the house look so I decided to keep it.

I wear a Medium/ 10 usually and had to exchange the large for an extra large. Unless you like your tank tops skin tight, I’d recommend sizing up. The fabric is pretty thin in this top but it’s perfect for layering under a shirt or sweater.

I bought this tank in 3 different colors! It has a lived-in feel, and can be dressed up or worn in the yard for gardening. Perfect summer wardrobe staple.

too small for me - very clingy

Runs small. I ordered a 2XL and there's no way it's a 18!! More like an XL or L. Seems like a cheap cotton that would be misshapen after a couple washes. Too bad, I have been looking for a style like this with wider shoulder straps.

I really like this tank top. I usually buy a small but got this in a medium so that it would not cling to my midsection. Sizing up worked well. The armpit holes were not too big with the larger size. It looks slightly nicer than a typical tank.

Fits like a real woman’s tank, shaped to compliment the female figure. I bought medium (5’8” 128#) and it fits comfortably and lays well. I’ve purchased more than one, great shirt in black. Goes with jeans but would be suitable with a summer skirt as well. Very classy cut but simple.

Love it! Can wear it casually, dress it up with a blazer, or wear for a workout.

Delicately cut with a flattering line, in love these by design but the material is too sheer, requiring a bra. In black I didn’t have this issue. It’s sad because absolutely love this design, extremely flattering and upscale look to this top. Had to return Sam’s got two in black.

I love the Madewell cotton tanks, but this one was quite sheer. I wanted it for working out and it's too sheer for that. It would be a good underlayer.

The cut is great but the material is so thin as to be see through. This makes it unwearable for me.

Style is great, but this top is shorter than I'd prefer.

runs small and short, i ordered an XL but it fits like a medium