Customer Reviews Madewell The Nye Penny Loafer

I have wide feet so they were kind of narrow at first but eventually stretched out to fit comfortably. Unfortunately, after wearing them for a couple weeks the stitching was coming undone and formed a hole. So I returned them and ordered a new pair. Sadly the same thing happened to the second pair after only one day. I knew they weren’t very sturdy/nice quality but didn’t expect them to break so easily.

The fit was great. Wide enough across my toe box. I really like the way they look.

I wear a Size 5, but this shoe felt a full size larger to me; therefore, I'm unable to comment on width and arch support. Otherwise, I sure do wish it came in a smaller size, because it is a very handsome shoe with classic loafer styling and soft leather.

Good leather. I know the soles are thicker now, but makes for a heavy shoe. Slips on my heels. I evidently wasn’t ready for the new look on me and am sending them back

this may run a smidge small? i typically wear a 9, but needed an 8.5 and there is still a bit of wiggle. But LOVE this shoe - it is classic, nicely made and comfortable from the start

Love these loafers! High quality leather and so comfortable. The finish is high-shine but not patent leather. These are a classic black loafer that will never go out of style.

Unfortunately I will be returning this shoe. It runs true to size and very well made. I have little to no arch which make the side of the shoe gap.

Not impressed by the quality of this shoe. The leather was papery and creased. The seams were raw, which might have looked better with quality leather. In all, an overpriced disappointment.

Cheaply made for this price point.

Poor quality, thin and papery leather for the price. Expected more from Madewell.

Love this shoe. It fits like a glove. Will purchase a second pair.

actually really impressed - nice suede lining in the heel back to keep from rubbing on the ankle. super comfortable right out of the box and tts.

I am a true 9 in most all shoes. This shoe was very tight and felt too short. Beautiful shoe - but hurt immediately to put on and try to walk. Sent back. Will try another brand.