Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Supersport Penny

I was never a loafer guy but my wife talked me into getting a pair of these. Wonderful shoe, fits well and super light. Was really impressed with the insoles.

Excellent quality Inn fit. Well thought out. Love these.

Great shoes. I have wide feet and the width options are excellent.

I have worn these probably 50+ times since purchasing. The are aesthetically please, very comfortable and sizing is spot on. The suede leather is certainly top shelf. I wear in business casual settings as well as with jeans when going out. The wear has not been too much of an issue. There are a few small areas, toe and heel, where the out-sole, which is dark brown, is a bit discolored and is a lighter shade of brown now. But nothing too noticeable. I have to really look to see it. Net is these are terrific loafers and I'd recommend.

love these, the look, the feel, pretty comfortable too.

My husband has a 10.5 EEE foot and its hard to find shoes especially comfortable shoes... Well I found them

My first driver in Demin suede! I had to pick these up and they are aesthetically appealing but comfortable as well, what a color fitting for the season.

they fit great, and look really sharp. low profile sole appears to allow the front/toe area to get scuffed up. could be related to how I walk - doesn't change my opinion on the purchase.

Excellent quality, fantastic look. Love these shoes

This loafer is stylish, comfortable and light as well as well made. Perfect for punching out 450 hp

Fits great, like all Allen Edmonds shoes. The Super Sport Penny Loafer is a fun casual shoe for evenings and weekends...and for anytime!

Tried Cavanaugh in many size variations and just a horrible fit for me. I'm 9.5D in 7 pairs of AE, yet the fit on these drivers in 9.5D are amazing!! Feel incredible, so comfortable, superb w/no socks.and look sharp! AE scored a bullseye on these!

Looks great. Size runs a bit tight in the width. Quality is excellent.

Love feel and appearance of the shoes. The heal (where they transition from rubber to leather) is wearing quickly after only a few wears .

This is the most comfortable pair of drivers I have ever owned, but the front & back of shows get scuffed up after first wear & continues to get worse the more you wear them.

Beautiful color! Love the style and feel. All day shoe

Great looking loafer! A bit tight over the top of the foot.

Excellent shoe in every way except the sizing. I have several AE dress shoes and sneakers in size 10 EEE that fit perfectly but for some reason this loafer in a size 10 EEE runs about an 1" longer in length which required me to send it back. I have re-ordered it in size 9 1/2 and a size 9 to see which size will actually work for me. We will see, I'm hoping one of those sizes will work as it is the perfect summertime loafer.

I bought a pair of these and they are just ok. The fit is not right, even though I purchased my normal size, and the leather already looks worn. I would not purchase again. I typically buy and like AE shoes.

The show is very narrow, tight across the top of the foot, but also very long. I am usually a size 11, ordered that size, and not only was it way too slim on the sides and top but my toes had way too much room once I did get them on. My other Allen Edmonds, the Cavanaugh penny loafer, are the same size and width and fit me perfectly. Very strange that these were designed so differently.

I wanted to love these. The toe area is very tight (depth wise, not width) and hurts after a couple hours. Never had this issue with other AE shoes. The shoe is delicate and showed a ton of scuff marks after only a couple of wears.

I own 3 x AEs - all sizes = 10.5 D. This is the first pair that runs extremely large and not in-line w/ AE sizing. Pictured: Super Sport Penny Loafer | Denim Suede in 10.5 D (purchased & returned in June 2023) vs. Siesta Key | Black Leather in 10.5 (purchased & loved since January 2019). The 2023 10.5 D is 1.5 inches longer than their comparable loafer.

I bought these a really beautiful shoes about a month ago. I've had the occasion to wear them 4 times, after the first two times wearing them, I immediately saw wear on the rear heals and the front tips. They were only used driving, walking short distances, and then full days in my office which is carpeted. A bit disappointed given the price.

I would say the shoe is not true to size and is tight in the back in particular.

I've been a customer for AE for close to 8 years. The quality over the years has plummeted to the point that this was my last purchase. The quality on these shoes are HORRIBLE! I've never had a show show wear and tear after the 3rd day I wore them. Buyer beware.