Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Randolph Bit

The leather is lush, shined, and high quality. Footbeds are not revolutionary comfort but comfortable for being on one's for stretches, nonetheless. I really like the soles that add a great modern look and help the whole shoe be lightweight, without sacrificing shoe durability or being too showy on look.

Wore these for my wedding and received compliments. A little uncomfortable at first but needed to be broken in and molded to my foot. I love Allen Edmonds.

Really nice craftsmanship on this shoe and stylish you have to order 1/2 up for comfortable fit

Classy loafer that is good for an upscale event or work. They do run narrow when compared to other AE products. I'm not sure why a 3E in this shoes varies so much from a 3E in other AE shoes. I think this is what's keeping it from being a 5 star review. I tried the shoe on in black in store and it felt fine. I ordered a chili and was more narrow so it may be this particular shoe. Order multiple size and multiple pairs of the right size to get the best shoe. V tread sole is a must.

Purchased 12 styles of these shoes over the years.Very high quality .The loafers fit and feel is excellent but the right shoe squeaks every time the heal hits.I have worn them three times.You can hear me coming! Any suggestions?

Fabulous shoe only need to adjust height of shoe side at ankle bone it is a bit to high and can cause discomfort

Shoe is comfortable and good looking. It's obviously made well as it's Allen Edmonds Only Complaint is that it's priced high

First pair of AE's that I have found pretty average

I don't believe the quality of the leather is the same as my older AE shoes.

Class and character, the best loafer I've ever owned. Lot's of women looking at my shoes and I can tell they love them.

I have 13 pairs of AE shoes that I actively wear (and many more that are retired) including 4 other pairs of Randolph loafers all in the same size. My initial impression was they were a little tight, but would loosen up over time and it was the same shoe that I purchased many times before. These shoes are so tight I cannot wear them more than a few hours at a time and have quit wearing them altogether. Very disappointed.

Not as comfortable as they advertise, I got the wide abd was still tight

I have numerous Edmond shoes. While the quality of these loafers is amazing - the size is too small. I brought them to Italy for 2 month vacation and can't wear them. Disappointed!

The shows look great but aren't comfortable. After wearing them for a week, I thought they may break in a little but they have not. If I could return them, I would.

Long time customer of AE but extremely disappointed on these bit loafers navy. I've kept with AE cedar shoe trees and have work once. After the day was done I looked down and they had so many deep creases in the toe box. Shoes appears like they had years of wear on them from someone that doesn't take care of their shoes. Extremely disappointed on these. Less then 70 days of ownership and one full day of wear.

I bought these in April for a special occasion. Let's just say I have not worn them since. I put them back in their box, placed them in the closet and forgot I had them. Needed a black loafer the other day and came across the box and tried them on once again. I wear the same size 13 in every shoe I own, but these definitely run smaller for some reason. Wish I would have know before hand. I will not be buying these again.

Extremely stiff. Strange dimensions, the top of my foot hurt like crazy when I wore them