Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Peonie

Wanted to like these but the front straps were digging in my feet. For me the front was a little narrow. Overall super cute shoe.

The ankle strap made the shoe move awkwardly with my foot, I never got the hang of walking comfortably in them. Returned. They were cute and otherwise comfortable.

Cute

The shoe was too narrow in the heel and too tight across the toes. The buckle rubbed against my ankle bone. I loved the look and they fit but were uncomfortable. Had to return

Says leather upper but shoe is Suede! Wearing the shoe in June. Would not have ordered if I knew it was Suede. Will return.

I like the shoes but when I opened the box they were just tossed in with no covering or packaging indicating that they were new. the ankle straps were undone like someone had just taken them off and put them in the box. I tried to order another pair but they were sold out and I needed them for a special outfit. I hadn't ordered from Zappos in a long time and this makes me wonder if your standards have slipped. Very disappointing for $140 shoes.

Looked very cheap.

These were a bit large but the worst thing was where the ankle strap hit-very uncomfortable. Too bad because they are super cute.

First tried these in patent leather. Could barely squeeze my toes under the straps, and when I finally was able to, the shoe appeared a half-size too long. Decided to try it in suede hoping for more give in the leather. Same problem. Finally decided I was trying too hard to make them work. Too bad. I really wanted them to!

Cute shoe. Tight across the top of the foot. Unfortunately they are poorly made - the heel broke the first day I wore it.

They are the cutest ! BUT the front straps killed my toe it’s not wide enough. Had to return it

I really wanted to love this shoe but it was too tight in the back. If it didn't squeeze my heel then I would have kept it.

The bottom of the shoe does not cover my foot. This would one thing if I had a wide foot, but my foot is actually a bit narrow. I have never had this problem before with any other shoe. It is frustrating because I thought that Sam Edelman was a reliable shoe brand. I own another pair that I love. This shoe has a nice style, but covering the bottom of my foot is a basic requirement.

So incredible painful. I’m normally an 8, ordered a 9 and they were so small and narrow I got blisters just trying them on. The leather is so hard and excruciatingly painful