Customer Reviews Carhartt Gilmore Waterproof 5" Soft Toe Hiker

I bought half a size up for good

They are very easy to pt on and off, light weight, you feel like walking on carpet. However, I have not tied them up all the way to the top because it's a hard material, going to use them for awhile before I can tie all the way up. I will buy them again.

I do not care for them at all. The size and width are way off making them very uncomfortable. I will be returning them.

The most uncomfortable shoes I have ever had on my feet. Construction seems good and they don't look bad, but my god are they uncomfortable. Whoever made these do not seem to know the shape of a human foot. Hint: the heel is NOT shaped like a cylinder. Carhartt is still my go to for work cloths but never again shoes.

This was my first time trying a hiking boot outside of some of the bigger names on the market (like Keen, Merrell & Danner. I figured Carhartt has a good reputation for making quality clothes, coats, etc., so why not give them a try. They look great, but are the most UNCOMFORTABLE boots I have ever purchased. I gave them the benefit of the doubt and waited a good two weeks to see if the break-in process just took longer than most other boots but NO! Now, I am stuck with these boots and, to be honest, would rather wear my year-old Keen hiking boots. And, Carhartt's return system is so strict, it won't allow me to return them (even after wearing them just once). Do yourself a favor and try them on at a store first.

Love this boot! Keeps my feet warm, dry, super comfortable and they look great.

Great boot , they feel good on my feet all day long.