Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Sylvia

The boots was nice but a little too pricey.

Boots are beautiful BUT as other reviewers have noted, the boot shaft is too tall. It hits the front of my knee and digs into the back. I am 5'4" and purchased them in a size 7. I do believe the shaft height depends on the shoe size as I tried a size 5.5 on in a dept store and thought the height would work, but when i bought them in my larger size it was too tall.

Way too wide - and I got M width

Love the look of these boots but the shaft was way too tale on my 5'2" frame. It jammed under my kneecap and into the back of my legs walking up stairs. Wish they came with a 1-2" shorter shaft height. Otherwise they were beautiful -- good quality leather (I tried black and spiced pecan) and comfortable even with the high heel. I also did not like that the inside of the heel looks unfinished; would prefer it to be wrapped in leather as well.

Absolutely massive on. My feet are sliding around. Usually a US women's size 9 is a Euro size 39, but in this shoe, they're calling the US size 9 equivalent to a Euro size 40. This shoe fits like a US size 40.

The color of these boots is beautiful. The calf is narrower than average in my experience--I've never been a wide-calf size in knee boots but I couldn't get these fully up on my calves, so I would need a wide-calf in order to try them on properly. The shape of the toe, however, was also not quite right for me. it pinched the toes, but seemed like the right fit on my foot otherwise.

If you have a high vamp, these boots will not fit.

Slightly slouchy, which is just not what I was wanting/hoping for. Also the calf part was weirdly unevenly gappy, more gappy in the back, which I just felt like looked weird / annoyed me. Would've kept otherwise.

these are very narrow, and very snug in the calf too

This boot is beautiful, but unfortunately came up too tall on me: I’m 5’1 for reference. If it was just an inch or two shorter, these would’ve been my favorite shoes for fall. I ordered both the normal and wide, and found the wide fit my calves much better.

It's a nice-looking boot but my foot was sliding forward and rubbing. Maybe I need to go down a size.

Not short girl friendly! I’m 5’4 which is a pretty standard height and these hit the middle of my knees. Had to return.

Lovely style however, slightly large in length and WAY TO WIDE in calves (did not order wide-calf).

I ordered because of the narrower look in the picture of the calf., but the calf was VERY wide. They looked ridiculous on my 5’2” frame. I returned both colors I ordered, too bad.

Super stylish boot but way more disco than I had hoped. Was hoping it would be more subtle metallic-sueded leather but it's pretty flashy -- too much so for work events.