Customer Reviews Circus NY by Sam Edelman Amy

I love my Circus Amy Lug Maryjane's! Every time I wear them I receive so many compliments. The sole is super thick and adds height to my 5'2 frame which I always appreciate. The bottoms have a flat platform, so even though they give you height, they do not feel like heels. The one problem I have with them is that they are pretty stiff. Because of this, I have to wear socks with them or they rub uncomfortably. I usually rock them with some striped knee highs and a cute skirt. I definitely recommend!

These are very comfortable shoes and fit great. They are stylish and go with many of my outfits. I like that these shoes give me some additional height. I feel pretty stable while walking in these shoes due to the platform. The design and quality of these shoes are great, and I hope to find new shoes like them to add to my collection.

These are really cute chunky Mary janes. If you like punk, chunky girl shoes you can't go wrong. Size seems correctmaybe a little big but not too much. I'd definitely recommend and buy others from this brand again.

Ahhh, these funky thangs. I was nervous I wouldn't be able to pull these off, but they're awesome. More comfortable than I expected. The adjustable strap on top is key.

These Circus NY 'Amy' shoes are the perfect mix of punk and preppy. They are shiny black patent with a buckle closure. They aren't overly heavy even though they have big chunky soles. Made well and comfy. I've worn them with jeans, cargo pants, dresses and skirts and they literally go with just about anything.

I bought this a month and am happy that it fits me so perfectly!! Quality of the product is so good !! Neatly designed !! Value of the product is also so good !! Perfect for winter season !! Highly recommended!!

I just wore these shoes for a New Year party, and they were so comfortable and cute. My feet were so cushioned all night for dancing and standing. The leather was firm without being too stiff and causing blisters, and they didn't need to be broken in

These are super cute and comfortable! I ordered them a half size bigger and they were the perfect size. At first glance, I thought they would be heavy, but they are really light. I wore them all day shopping and they were very comfortable. The inside sole almost feels like a memory foam. Would definitely recommend these!

I received these shoes a couple of weeks ago and I gave them to my daughter. They are comfortable and really cute with any outfit. She really likes them and is happy with the look, style and how comfortable they are.

After receiving the Sam Edelman's Circus NY Amy shoe, I wore them for several days and I cannot say enough good about not only how cute they are but also how comfortable they are. Since I need some cushion in my shoe, this was the first thing that caught my eye. The cushioned insole is amazingly comfortable! After reading reviews on this shoe, I chose to get a half size smaller, and it was a perfect fit! These chunky style, black Mary Jane shoes have a heel that I can walk in without worrying about falling in. These shoes have an approximate 2-1/2 inch wedge, lug-style heel/platform that is so fashionable and in style right now. I was so happy that I was not the shortest one at the latest family gathering for once! I love how it has the rounded toe and an adjustable buckle to get just the right fit. They are just shiny enough without being too shiny. Whether paired with jeans or a dressier style pant and top, the look is adorable, and they fit right in with both types of pants. I am going to try pairing it with a longer style skirt soon and can't wait to see how it looks!

I get so many compliments on how cool my shoes are. I wear them to work and they are super comfortable even after a long shift my feet aren't sore! They have held up well and everything is still in working order. Love the high sole makes me look taller!! All around great shoe!

I wasn't quite sure about these shoes at first but after finding the right outfit to wear with them, I'm obsessed! They're super chunky but not heavy or hard to walk in. They can be dressed up or down. I found them to be true to size and very comfortable. I'd definitely pick these over heals any day!

Absolutely love these shoes. They are way more comfortable than I expected them to be. So cute and the perfect shoes to wear for a night out or even to a concert. Can wait to put together the cutest outfits with these shoes!

I'm in love with these shoes, they are so very comfortable and are very well made. They look great with so many different styles. I would recommend this brand of shoe for anyone to update their style.

I love these shoes , I wear them almost everyday with my jeans. They are very very comfortable don't even feel like you are wearing shoes. I love how easy they are to keep clean, wash them off with a damp rag and they look good as new. I have had alot if people ask me where I got these shoes from cause they like the look of them. I totally recommend these shoes to family and friends you won't regret getting you a pair of them they are so comfy and love the look.

I got these for my daughter because she is obsessed with this style of loafers. I knew she would love the chunky look of these! I was a little worried that they might be heavy for her, but she wears them to school all day and says they are the most comfortable loafers she has. They fit great and are true to size. The buckle is simple and easy to adjust. They can be dressed up with a cute skirt or dressed down with a pair of comfy jeans. They are perfect all around! I'll be purchasing myself a pair soon!

I absolutely loved wearing these shoes, although chunky, they are surprisingly light, you definitely do not feel like you are carrying such a large platform. The platform itself is nice and wide providing a well balanced surface, and the shoe is comfortable. It does have a bit of a plasticky look to it, a fact i did not mind as it actually completed to total look.

These are so well made, and the perfect platforms. You can honestly dress up or dress down with these shoes. They are slightly heavy but you adjust to them very quickly. The only problem I have ran into is they are a tad too lose so my heel lifts when I walk.

I love how you don't have to forsake cuteness to get comfort with these shoes. They're absolutely adorable, AND don't hurt my feet whatsoever even after a long night out! Insanely satisfied and impressed.

These are adorable & so comfortable. I am a tad uncoordinated in heels but these give me the height with no wobbles.