Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Gracelyn Chain Loafer

I Love The Look of These Shoes, especially the sparkly little silver highlight between the shoe's sole and the upper leather! Chef's Kiss. That said, in all my 60+ years, I have NEVER had a shoe that fit so poorly and caused so much pain. That's really saying something when I can still wear 4 inch heels sometimes! A stylist (whom is no longer in business) bought these for me, so J&M wouldn't have a receipt of my purchase to facilitate a return. ......... The ill fit details - My heel slipped out when attempting to walk and I wrongly thought that inserts would save the day because I genuinely LOVE the look of these shoes. However, the thing that really made me give up trying with these, despite my adoration of the look, is how excruciatingly narrow the toe box is on these shoes. I bought the Silver Metallic Sheepskin in an 8, which is my normal size. Hope this review helps someone and it was validating to read the comments from those with narrow feet who say they fit them well. J&M, you missed the mark on sizing here.

Too narrow at toe box.

Absolutely loved the bronze, but the finish started wearing off the first time I wore them. 4 wears in and there are large bare patches in the finish. Really disappointing because I love the look and they are incredibly comfortable, and this is my first J&M purchase.

First time I wore them the finish on the side wore off.

The fit of the shoe is amazing, however, the silver metallic finish started pealing off less than two weeks after I bought them. I ended up returning the shoes.

terrible material sound I will return this item.

Bulky