Customer Reviews Marc Joseph New York Broad Street Pump

These shoes are beautiful but they run small. I have a narrow foot so I ordered my usual size. I exchanged them for a half size larger in and they seem to fit well and feel comfortable. I would order another pair if they were available in my size.

Fit is very good but there is stretching the leather so I wish I went down 1/2 size. Gorgeous shoe. Quality leather. Best part of Zappos is their staff however who went out of their way to help me with these.

I really liked these shoes, but they were way too tight on my toes. I wish they came in wide!!

Nice shoe-too large

Initially, I had purchased these shoes in my usual shoe size, but they were too tight, so I returned them and went up a half a size, and they fit comfortably. I like the modern look of the shoe, and the light color for my spring and summer wardrobe.

Narrow toe box. Leather is nice but stiff.

I ordered a size 7, which is my usual size, have to return for size 6.5 -- It's a beautiful shoe

These shoes were just a tad too long, but I might could have put in a heel pad at the back of the heel to make them work. The deal breaker was that both shoes squeaked with every step. I was also not happy that this Zappos order arrived poorly packaged, loose in an Amazon box. I suspect that they were a return, and that that person threw out the Marc Joseph box before making a decision.

They were too tight across the ball of my foot.

They slip off my feet in the heels, but fit right through the toe area so not sure how to size for that

Nice quality, attractive, shoes but they cut in the top of my foot in a painful way. The toe box should come up a little higher.

Not my style. A little too boxy.

Nice shoes, but I recommend buying them elsewhere. Zappos sent me a bag of loose shoes, without even a shoebox, let alone any other protective packaging!

This shoe definitely runs narrow and small. Cute shoe, padded foot bed looks like it would be nice if the shoe fit.

Felt a little short and hit my bunion scar at exactly the wrong place. Color was nice but didn't like seam at the instep. Felt a little stiff.

Runs small. Had to return. Style as depicted.

They fit alright but they squeak.

These shoes were the perfect style with a low heel. However, they seemed narrow and a little short. They seemed to be made really well. I’m sad that they didn’t work for me.

I felt that it was too small for me especially left side of width. I should select wider or half size bigger. Also, shoes are bit heavy.

The front opening of the shoe pressed on the joint of my big toe so it was painful to wear these shoes.

I was sent patent leather rather than pebbled leather

The quality of the leather is bad. It has a scratch on the shoe already