Customer Reviews Marc Joseph New York Naples

I ordered a medium width, but these were really wide and actually noticeably gaped open on both sides. I've never had this problem before so I don't think it's my foot! I'll be returning them. They are pretty comfortable, but I've seen other cuter shoes in this basic style.

Nice quality and comfortable support. I ordered a 9 ( usually wear 8.5-9) they rubbed a bit on the heel when I walked they were too wide on the sides.

I like the look of this loafer but it definitely runs large. I have to exchange it for a smaller size.

The shoe was too wide and felt sloppy. I really wish it wasn’t because the leather was so nice and the color was a true deep navy. I had to return the shoe.

So cute but ran very wide. Gaped around the midfoot.

They are a nice shoe just felt too big both in size and width

The size 6.5 toe area was too tight and the rest of the shoe was too wide, including the heel being too big. Too bad. The 7, which I usually wear, was too big all over. I loved the style and it looked like it was well made, other than the sizing, which was way off, making the shoes unwearable no matter how hard I tried to make them work (inserts...). The above "fit" options don't allow for too wide AND too narrow all at the same time, which was the case here.

This shoe is so nice. I just wanted an everyday flat and comfortable shoe and this was it. I wear a size 12 in women's shoes. But this shoe is like a half size smaller than a 12. More like an 11 or 11.5. So disappointed. Had to return them.

Liked the shoe and color but think it was too narrow for me

Great but I bought two by mistake

Bought two by mistske

Fabulous shoe- sooo comfortable!!

I tried 2 pair of loafers before ordering this pair. I really like these. They’re a soft leather and worn all day brand new. They never hurt a spigeon. I’m happy with them.

I have many pairs of MJNY shoes and this is the first time a 6.5 worked better than the 7. I'll be returning the 7s. Love these loafers!

These are beautiful leather loafers, buttery-soft and quite cushioned. I have high arches and found the sizing to be true to what I normally wear, which is a 6.5 medium. I didn't find the toe box too narrow or the middle too wide; it was just right! Highly recommend!

Very comfortable and stylish would recommend

Love the shoes! Very comfortable.

These beautiful, classis loafers feel like comfy slipper.

My new favorite shoe!

These are super cute shoes but they run small. Had to return and try a size up.

I bought these in black grainy and in tan. The black fit me better, the tan felt narrower, and I thought the tan color was a little muddy, although the leather felt like good quality. I do have a wider foot, so it's hard to find a loafer. I am usually an 8 and tried a 9, but too narrow for me.

These were much too narrow for me. The leather felt great and I think they would have stretched with some wear-in, however the sole is so narrow that my foot simply would have hung over the side of the shoe. Great look for a narrower foot than mine, beautiful color.

These shoes were very comfortable but I returned them because I felt the style wasn’t quite what I was looking for. It would’ve been nice if it had contrast stitching.

I wear a 9, I ordered the 8.5 because reviews said they were larger. I have to send back to get the 9. Cute shoes, nice quality.