Customer Reviews Marc Joseph New York East Village

The shoes are well made and comfortable but way to wide in the heel for me. I do have narrow heels so they may fit someone else fine.

I liked the style and the fit but the shoes squeaked and flared out at the sides. Wish I could keep but sending them back because of the squeak and flare

I wanted to love these, but as other reviews have stated they bag at the sides, which makes them too big. My foot kept sliding right out at the heel. I wish they fit true to size and were not so wide. I had to sadly return.

Also, the shoes were too shiny making them look cheap. Beautiful loafers look. Traditional.

I ordered the mint green color, which was really pretty. The shoe ran a little small, however, and when I walked in them, the sides flared out.

This shoe is much lighter in color than it appears online. It is not aubergine. It's a medium to bright purple. It would have looked better and dressier if the color had been deeper purple. They do feel a little loose. I can wear them without socks. They're just okay.

I just walked around on carpet a few minutes but it was not comfortable.

I love black patent leather loafers and these shoes are cute and stylish, but I did not find them to be comfortable. The black patent leather uppers are very stiff and the soles are hard. The insoles are not easily removable if you are thinking of inserting a pair of orthotics.

I ordered my usual size (8) and found that, similar to other reviews, the heel was too wide. There was a gap at the back of about 1/2 inch. Even with heel inserts my foot still came out. Not sure a half size smaller would solve the issue, as my toes fit comfortably. Just something about the overall design of the heel area is off.

Like the shoes but need to try a 1/2 size smaller

I ordered the red ones, and they are coral. Not al all as shown. Bummer.

Hurt my Arthritic right foot

Not real penny loafers. More like slip ons.

Beautiful Shoe! Too big in the heal... flops on my foot.

Left shoe felt mid-shaped.