Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari Oiled Leather

I originally ordered a size 38 since my regular size runs 7 or 7 1/2. That pair was too big. I sized down to a 37 and they fit perfectly. I love Birkenstocks because they are comfortable and last for years!

Love the color and fit/comfort has remained the same since first wearing this style 10 years ago.

These are my favorite sandals. Great fit and comfort.

this fit great and are extremely comfortable

I’m a regular Birkenstock wearer and purchaser. Love them! I love how great the service is with Zappos. Quick delivery with no issues!

Most comfy shoe for my feet. Thanks

I wear a solid size 8 and I was a little nervous reading reviews that it might be too big. However I ordered a 38, regular, and it fits like a glove! These sandals are wonderfully comfortable with two adjustable straps. They look like flip flops but properly buckled down they do NOT flop. They stick to your food and look just super cute. I have a slight bunion on my right foot but there was plenty of room for my toes. It's too cold to wear them out and about right now but I tried on both and wore them around the house and I think I'm in love.

True to size 8 with super soft leather and adjustable width. Fast shipping!

They are comfy but a little too long, normally a 37

I usually wear a size 7B, but get a 6-6.5 (37) Regular. I have for years, and like this fit and look. I need good shoes with arch support, these do this. so comfortable wear them all spring-fall, and in home in winter!

Although these felt different than my Teva flip flops, it is a good different. Great arch support, immediate sculpting to my feet, no blisters at all. Fabulous shoes and I have feeling my back will thank me. Just what I expected from Birkenstock and just what I got!

Comfy sandals

The color was beautiful and exactly what I was looking for.

I love this style of Birkenstocks. I’ve had major reconstruction of my left foot. My surgeon likes the support and the stiff sole not allowing extreme flexion of the ball of the foot. Crazy comfortable!!!

Love these and got them in black and navy. Comfortable and stylish.

Fit great, comfortable. I have been wearing Birkenstocks for 30 years. Love the styles and colors!

I love these booties. Have them in Navy and green and now black. Comfortable and classy

Love these sandals, they look as good with shorts as a long skirt. Dress them up or down!

Thanks, Zappos. The exchange for right size by your rep was fast and courteous. I ordered the 39 which is what I wear in Birkenstock Arizona but it was way larger than the Arizona. I normally wear a 7-1/2 to 8 in shoes and boots. I like the Mayari oil rubbed leather as much as the Arizona suede. There is no break in with either.

I was worried that there would be a break-in period, but these fit & felt great right out of the box. I wear sandals every day, but I occasionally get foot pain because of my high arches. I have an older pair of Birkenstocks, but they're purple & a bit boxy. I love them, but they're not right for everyday wear. These can be my everyday sandals. They don't have the same "frumpy" look that you might associate with Birkenstocks, but they do have the same support, quality, and comfort. Glad I found them!

I normally wear a Narrow, but was hoping with the style I could tighten the straps enough to be able to wear the medium width. The bed (sole) of the shoe is a lot wider than I expected and the straps make the shoe too wide. I know after wearing them and the leather stretching, I wouldn't be able to keep them on. I've been wearing Birkenstocks since we were stationed in Germany in the 90's. They are my summer shoes. I have been hoping to find the Mayari in a narrow width for 2 years now. I'm so disappointed these didn't fit.

Had these sandals a few years back and was soooo nice to say hello to them again! Cute style. Great fit.

These did not disappoint. Birkenstocks are my go to for arch support and comfort.

These are gorgeous and stylish, but sadly ran a little small for me, so I will unfortunately have to return for a larger size. :(