Customer Reviews NYDJ Fay

Aaaah! These were hard to return, because they are a lovely faille fabric and a very pretty heel with a nicely squared but not clunky toe. It's a very very feminine and pretty shoe! I was looking for a pump to wear for nicer evenings out while traveling to Edinburgh this fall and I got a little nervous about the fabric upper and its durability under rainy conditions. The shoe is not inexpensive and since I'm doing a bit more pre-trip shopping I reluctantly returned. I'm having returner's remorse now though so don't hesitate - they are so nice!

Oh how I wish they had been comfortable in the large toe area because the shoes were gorgeous but sadly they just rubbed in the wrong area.

I ended up putting foot liners in my shoes but that's because I have a narrow foot. The length of the shoe was perfect and the fact that they had a little rubber on the bottom and the ball/toe was great - no slipping! I wore all day and night to a wedding, and walking in Duluth MN, which is hilly!

This shoe is really nice. Good fit. Quality materials - cool heel. Had foot surgery so I haven't worn them for a full day, but they are true to size. Thanks for making quality shoes in a size 5!

Although I don't wear a wide shoe, as a plus-sized woman I do have a wider foot. These fit perfectly in my normal size (9). They did not gap, squeeze or pinch my foot in any way. I am quite pleased with these.

Comfortable shoe, great height.

I can’t evaluate the comfort because the shoe was so large on my foot that I couldn’t keep it on to walk. I will order a smaller size. The fabric of the shoe helps make a shoe with a blocky heel more dressy

The quality should be better, the shoe should be softer. Beautiful but returned.

Beautiful shoes. The toe box was too tight that is why I am returning them. The length and width (excluding the toe box) itself was fine.

I ordered a half size smaller when the size 7 pair were too large. The 6 1/2 gapped badly at the sides. It was very obvious when I looked down at my feet.

The shoe I received was different than the shoe shown in the picture. I expected a square toe box, yet the shoe I have is pointed. The heel is much larger. It's really a different shoe. While beautiful, it is not what I want or need. Sigh. I just want what is in the picture as that is exactly what will work for me. Customer service was wonderful on the return. Kudos to them.

I needed these shoes to work for me!! I need them for an event this week; however, they are way too big. I am a true 8.5 and these gapped at the sides and also in the heel. I could have fit at least a pencil in between my foot and the back of the shoe. The worst part is that they squeak when you walk. I would have sucked it up and made them work for a day, but I cannot wear squeaking shoes to an interview. They are beautiful, and if they fit, I would have ordered them in all colors.

Nice looking shoe, but huge.

The shoes look fabulous. After reading the reviews, I decided to purchase my usual size, 8M. I was a little nervous because I usually purchase an 8W. Out of the box, the shoes fit great and were super comfortable. I wore them to an event and after an hour or so I had a hard time keeping the shoes on my foot. Upon wearing them they became way too big - too wide and my foot would not stay in them. I came home disappointed because I now own $149 pair of shoes that I will sadly never be able to wear again.