Customer Reviews Sofft Pecola

These boot are gorgeous the material felt sooo silky the sole was amazing. Unfortunately I got wide feet (10.5 cm) the were extremely tight

Fabulous, gorgeous boots. I was torn between the 9.5 and 10 because I read that the boots ran large. But I ended up choosing my regualr boot size of 10 since I like to put cushy insoles in them. They are boots I'll take on vacation to Italy this fall since they're comfortable and waterproof. I like a little extra room for swelling when walking many, many miles per day.

Love the look and feel of these booties, size felt about a 1/2 size too big.

Feel pretty good, look good, and I'm happy to have good traction and water repellant boots!

Nice looking & comfortable. They run about a half size large so order accordingly.

Other than the boot was huge it was very comfortable and you would love it if it fits. Very nice, soft suede and very comfortable sole. I have a very small foot and my true size is 5-5.5. I settle for size US size 6 which used to be EU size 36. Now some brands have redefined a US size 6 as a EU size 37. An EU size 37 is actually a US size 6.5-7. I've been fooled too many times and now I, sadly, have to add Sofft to the list of shoes that will never have my size as US 6 is their smallest.

I wanted to love this boot because it felt so comfortable right out of the box. The leather is soft, it is true to size and the soles offer nice cushion. Unfortunately, the toe box is really long and it makes the book look clunky. I am regretfully returning it.

I'm normally between a 7 and 7.5 medium width. I went with 7 because of comments. These boots lean slightly narrower. Not enough to be considered "narrow" vs medium but enough to wear a thinner sock. That being said, these boots are lightweight and very comfortable!

I loved these and wanted to keep them but they were waaaaay too small and narrow. I ordered the size I generally wear but could not even get my foot into these. But the shoe was very soft and very nice quality.

This is for the narrow-foot consumers… I have a very narrow foot. Narrow shoes are not cute…at all…so I’m often looking for medium width shoes that run narrow. I normally wear a 10.5, but a 9.5 fit just right. Several reviews said they run big, and I found this to be true. They aren’t narrow, but they aren’t too wide. They were loose out of the box, but once I added an insole they fit much better. I also wear a thicker sock. I wanted a chunky sole boot without a heel because I’m tall and also wanted a more casual, comfortable boot. These will do just fine.

The looked great, and felt good, but were too narrow for my feet (normally wear an 11B).

I usually wear size 10 which I ordered for these boots. They were about 1/2 size to big, but barely wide enough. I thought they would be too narrow if I tried the 9.5. The leather is beautiful, and they were comfortable to walk in. Some with a higher instep may not like the way they walked though.

This boot is sooo cute but unfortunately sizing for this company is US 6 = EU 37 which means this shoe is a full size too big. US 6 used to equal EU 36 - not EU 37... and of course they don't make the shoe smaller than a US 6... so back they go!

I wear a 8.5 - 9 regular width boot. These were so very narrow! I need a wider toebox (not /actual/ wide, but wider than normal, apparently) and couldn't even get my foot into the 8.5 of these. The 9 I could get on, but only with very thin socks, and I had my doubts that it would have stretched sufficiently. Very sad, because the materials and footbed were really nice. Style-wise, they're not as cool as they looked in the photos. They're a little long and a little too pointy-toed, and with the wrinkly leather and chunky sole it just looked odd. Like, given the sole and the leather, the shape should have been blockier. Oh well. They certainly seem like a well-made shoe.

These are such cute boots! They are light, have good arch support and look good. The only problem is the width. The 8.5 were too tight and the 9 was too big. I think maybe if they were both a little tight then you could break them in and they would loosen up with the material that they are. I couldn’t do that because I would need two different sizes to do that. I’m sad that I have to return both pair.

These run small across the arch of the foot. Also you cannot add inserts. Super cute but I have to send them back

Super cute boot. Absolutely not comfortable though - stiff all around with no actual arch or foot support.

If you have a high instep and/or even slightly wide feet, these are likey not the boots for you. They are adorable but I couldn't fully get my size 9 foot into them.

Size and fit is great. Color is much lighter than I thought it would be. They came in with a big stain on the leather, which is very unfortunate.

I tried 2 sizes and both fit fine in the toe box, but the heel slipped over an inch. Plus, the 2nd pair that were sent to me were obviously used; not in the original box, missing original packaging and scuffed.

Huge.

This boot is supposed to have an arch support pad but the problem is that the pad is too high and they put it to close to the toe box, so I felt like I was stepping on a bubble and that was uncomfortable. I returned the shoes.

Very nice looking shoes. For me they were a little tight across the front of the foot and way to big in the heel. Had to send them back.