Customer Reviews PIKOLINOS Aldaya W8J-3541C2

These loafers are great. The leather is soft and doesn't seem like they will need any 'breaking in'. They are "true to size" if you follow the US to EU guideline - which is that a US 8.5 is an EU 39 and a US 9 is an EU 40. I would advise that you do not follow the Zappos suggestion of an EU 39 being a US 8.5-9. This is incorrect and will necessitate an exchange. Stylish shoes worth the price!

Nice cushy footbed. Cute colors. Good spin on a classic! I’m a true 9-9.5 and always order a 40 - this was the correct choice!

These are so cute! Unfortunately, there was too much room in the heel for me. I think these are probably not a good option for a narrow foot.

The most beautiful shoe I’ve seen in a long time. Very comfortable and lightweight. I have a chubby foot but not quite wide width and these fit perfectly. Get them while you can. I would buy two pairs if I could afford it.

Forget these if you have a high instep, I couldn't even get my feet in them.

Fits my feet perfectly, the leather is soft and doesn't hurt my heel right out of the box, I think breaking-in period will be minimal. Roomy toe box without being square. Very stylish top stitch, two-tone makes the style more casual, and the lighter leather color lets you wear it summer through fall. I like them very much and will be keeping them.

Usually wear a 38, but had to size up to 39 in these.

I really love the look of these shoes. The fit was horrible. Both shoes rubbed the outside of my feet. They hurt immediately.

I've had several pairs of Pikolinos. Comfortable. Good quality. These had a comfortable toe box and sole. However, I have a narrow heel and it kept slipping out of these shoes. Disappointed.

I typically wear an 8.5 and had to go up a size to 40 (9.5-10). I love the shoes, they are comfortable and I always get compliments when I wear them. Quality is excellent.

Love these shoes. Get compliments for them. Very comfortable. Feel true to size.

I'm a pretty solid 10.5 and the 10.5-11 size fits perfectly. These are comfortable shoes with moderate arch support. I like that the soles have treads and won't be too slick in wet weather. I purchased the lighter color and the picture is accurate to what was received. The burnished look to the leather gives a slight Western look. Nice variation to the traditional penny loafer.

I usually wear an 8.5 and had to go up a full size for these. I love the shoes. They are very comfortable and I get lots of compliments on them.

Wonderful all around, nice fit and handsomely crafted. Highly recommend it.

Good quality and style

Loose heel and very narrow toe box. I’m normally a 38/7.5 medium width. Quality construction and nice colors, just a bad fit for me.

Bought the off white / brown version which were unique and super cute. They fit true to size. Very good quality, although a bit over-priced.

Love everything about these shoes! Except the price. I am still debating on whether I will keep them. They are comfortable and super soft leather and the footbed is soft and OH SO CUTE. I just don't know that I want to spend $170

Love them as does everyone at work!

Love these shoes. Soft leather and they have a stylish flare about them. Great with jeans or slacks to add some stand-out style!

It’s a beautiful shoe and I wished it fit me. I have a medium/standard width but this shoe was too narrow. The length was fine but it hurt in the heal.

Really cute shoe that did not work for me. Tight across the "penny band" and it made my foot look wide. (It is wide! But I can make it look narrower with the right shoe).

Bummed these were too small. My other Pikolinos are a 38, so I ordered these in 38, now they're sold out. Bummer, they looked really cute and felt as though they would have been comfy if they were the right size.

Thes are so cute but sadly I am between sizes on these.

These are beautiful shoes. Sadly, they are too small for me. I wear 8.5-9 in shoes. I have a normal/slightly wide foot. These felt a full size small and narrow. I hate it but I have to return.