Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Emmett Penny

Great fit, super comfortable right out of the box and look great at work or leisure!

The leather is a bit more orange than the photos; however, it should mellow over time. Overall, I am very satisfied with the shoe.

JM makes the most comfortable shoes i wear. The fit is perfect and the color goes well with any slacks i have.

I love J&M shoes. Been wearing them for over 40 years! As I have aged I need a lighter shoe for comfort but also style.

The shoes run a bit large, but they are quite nice. They are also affordable.

Very good looking casual shoe. Elongated style makes my fit slightly long.

Fits a little more narrow at width than most, otherwise great feel Nd quality

classic look, very modern, and every situation (informal/formal).

Wanted a comfortable slip on that looked bit more polished and these delivered. Material and finish is top notch. Fit was slightly big based on my usual size order but not clown shoes

Good weekend shoe than can go to the office. The fit on the medium seems a bit wide, but not enough to retun the shoes. The color and quality for the price are very good.

Awesome

Nice shoes weren't my style

Beautiful shoe, material and color are great. Fitting is not good, too tight. Needs to be a little wider

Acceptable and comfortable

Loved the show but was too big. Need to drop down a 1/2 size.

These are a nice looking, quality offering from JM, but I ended up returning them because they seem to fit a half size smaller than my other JM shoes. Also, I didn't feel like they offered me enough lateral support.

These are great high quality shoes. With slips ons I went a size smaller but these are still slightly bigger than expected.

Product was very well made and super nice, but it was tighter than expected and very difficult to put on. The leather likely would have loosened up after some wear, but it wasn't comfortable to me. Had to return.

Too wide, too large despite sizing down 1/2 size. Now I know why the price was reduced so much. With thick socks I can probably make them work when it's cold, but their utility for summer wear is in doubt. Pity.

I like the design and the shoe is very comfortable. But just after 2 months of wear, the soles on both shoes have worn to the white padding. The shoe also started squeaking as I walked, making it unwearable in public. It's such a waste as the leather on top was still in excellent condition. I weigh about 200 lbs. My daily commute in NYC involves about 30 mins of walking.

Too big. Didn't keep