Customer Reviews Trotters Honesty

This shoe is a terrible quality, and I’m surprised Trotter’s wants their name on it. The “leather” is like cardboard, no lining, doesn’t bend to walk. Looks cheap and is badly designed. Suggest you Skip this one!

The fit was not bad--pretty comfortable with no breaking in. However, I just felt dowdy--it is a very mother of the bride type shoe. It would be cute on someone in their 20s, but for a 50-something, it made me feel old. Returned.

Very cute, but the medial upper edge is quite sharp. Had to go back :(

Not comfortable. I have an older pair of Trotters that are extremely comfortable and fit perfectly. Very disappointed in this particular shoe.

Shoes were a bit short.

Too large. No support

I ordered a size 9 narrow. When the package arrived, the box was labeled a 9N on the outside. I have one size 9 shoe and one size 7 shoe in the box. But the size 9 I normally order was too big and too wide.

Ordered the silver in 11 M. Just received it yesterday. It is so small I can barely get my foot into it!!!!I I’m sure it has to be a size 9z I wear a size 11 M in every Trotters shoe I own. I have this same shoe I’m Black. Don’t know what’s going on!

The shoe is as pictured. I liked it. It just too narrow and a 1/2 size too small.

Didn’t like the feel. Too small for wide feet

The leather was stiff and hurt my feet

Unfortunately, I received two completely different sized shoes of the same style. One shoe was a 7 N, the other shoe was a 9 N.

Pretty but painful. Length was good, fit across forefoot was good, but the material was so high and stiff along the ankle bones, it was excruciatingly painful to wear these shoes. Try wear-testing your products first, Trotters!!

This Trotters Honesty shoe only has one good thing about it and it is the style. The quality is horrible. The leather is paper thin and feels like it is going to peel off with minimal wear. The inside was rough especially in the heel. It runs large. I ordered from Zappos and another pair from another store and returned both of them. It seems like Trotters is no longer interested in providing good quality comfortable shoes. Very dissatisfied and disappointed as I own many pairs of Trotters shoes. Will not buy any other Trotters shoes online again.