Customer Reviews Cole Haan Nantucket 2.0 Penny Loafer

I have been only wearing once in a while to "break them in" but so far comfortable and fit true to size. Real test is I am wearing to a football game this weekend where I must do a bit of walking and stairs. Hopefully no blisters or rubbing spots. Love the preppy look so me!! Wil be my new go to "casual dressy" shoes with jeans and shorts!

Instep is narrow. Looks great and feel good. It may be to it being a jean fabric.

The shoe runs long. I wish I had known that when I ordered my size.

Too snug, ordered size 9 need a 9 1/2

Extremely comfortable. As comfortable as expensive tennis shoes. With you had them in leather like before, not suede

The shoe is super nice as expected. The only disappointment that I have is that you can see a little opening in the shoe perimeter where sole meets the leather. I think this would not be an issue on the darker shoe. I got it at final sale deal, so I don't know if can really exchange it.

Disappointed with the in soles (not enough supports) but thankfully the insole comes out and we used some better ones

Comfortable casual shoe for work. It is flexible as well as cushioning for my feet.

I like my new silver Nantucket 2.O loafers, not love. I have 5 other colors of the loafers purchased past 3 years and Cole Hahn changed the manufacturer and or designer. Please go back to the previous years design.

Comfortable and fits well

I like the shoe overall. I returned b/c the size qas too large.

I really like the style and color, but they are a little narrow. I did decide to keep them hoping that they will stretch a little.

Very lightweight and comfy! These shoes are like walking on a cloud! They are super cute, but slightly snug/narrow (I wear a 6.5 regularly and these feel just a smidge small, but maybe will stretch out some?)

Runs Big. I have been a size six for most of my adult life, so I was surprised to find that I was walking right out of these shoes. They are very comfortable but awaiting a half size down to exchange them.

have purchased many of this style over the years. The quality has really taken a nose dive . These were a bit disappointing. The material was thin. Not what I expected from a quality brand.

I can't fit them same size as previous purchases. I would probably go up a size as these were a no return purchase.

Cute but you designed this version with a higher vamp and it looks much less streamlined. I LOVED the older version of the Nantucket loafer

I love the loafer look for summer with the bright, white sole. But they were at least a 1/2 size too big and I have always worn 8 1/2 in Cole Hahn shoes.

I loved the white pair I purchased so much that I bought these lovely denim ones, too. Unfortunately, even though they are the same size, these will not go on my feet.

This loafer looks comfortable, easy to put on and wear all day. Cole Haan's size 7 is a perfect fit usually, yet this attractive shoe in size 7 felt 2 sizes too large, with a 1" gap at the heel. I could easily "walk out" of the shoe. Unfortunately, this stylish shoe was not a good fit for me.

Love the the look of the shoe. Tried two sizes. Both were too narrow. Had to reture both pair.