Customer Reviews Madewell The Charley Double-Strap Slide Sandal

I'm A 7.5-8 in most brands but at madewell, my size is a solid 8. These fit perfectly in an 8 and are so so comfortable. My first impression was too clunky ....but I saw them on petite blogger site (pumpsandpushups.com) and thought I would give them a go. They're so light and cute on! I'm pleasantly surprised that I really like these. The nude shade is perfect for elongating short legs :). Perfect sandal for mini dresses shorts and jeans.

Really cute but only wore a handful of times before the front of the shoe started to show some rips where the toe is. DO NOT BUY these are horrible quality!

Really cute and comfortable but they squeezed with every step. I had to send them back ?

These sandals seem comfortable, but I just didn't care for the look. I felt like my feet looked really big and clunky. Additionally, as some reviewers commented, they made a squeaky sound when walking that I wouldn't want to deal with...back they went.

Runs small. They may feel better after they’re broken in but I doubt it.

Beautifully made.

Really cute and comfy. Got the blush color after Madewell ran out of my size

Lots of weird things with this shoe. The upper does not feel like leather, it feels like plastic against your sole. Makes an odd squeak / squish when you walk. The top strap feels comfortable when standing, but kind of pushes your foot backward off the back of the shoe when you step. I sized down to a 5.5 from my usual 6 in hopes of avoiding the phenomenon as described by other reviewers, but alas, same problem. Oh, also, my box arrived destroyed! Literally half the shoe box was torn off and missing (see photo). The shoes were well wrapped in paper so they look brand new, miraculously. They are cute and very comfortable when you are just standing in them though; wish the construction was better so I could have kept them. Hoping my return isn't denied due to the state of the shoe box.

They feel comfortable but they are "pleather" and feel cheap for the price. The soles felt slippery and I figure they would hurt after awhile. And my feet would stick when it was hot. I am used to the Birkenstock suede. The style is cute. No real support.

Fit and size was good, super cute, but slippery!! I bought these to wear out to the pool deck and they have no grip. Had to return. Sad because I’ve wanted them for months.