Customer Reviews Trotters Lizzie

Based on the other reviews, I decided to order the wide width (in cognac) and I'm so happy I did! I'm a US 9 and they fit true to size but definitely would have been too narrow for my feet in the regular width.. They're super cute and give me that retro preppy 80s/90s feel and are super cute with jeans and a blazer or boyfriend jeans and a cozy long cardigan. They have a menswear feel that's still feminine and I love them!

Love the way they look but definitely runs small

This is a good looking shoe for everyday, especially with jeans and slacks. I had 2 pair years ago, and was hoping they would came out again. I purchased all the colors. I wear 13N.

I have worn Munro shoes for years, but this was sized way off! I had to return it! This boot felt like it's size was off one or two sizes bigger.

I definitely ordered up after reading the reviews. Normally need a 9W, sometimes can get away with a 9.5 if not too narrow. Ordered the 10D and they fit perfectly.

The 8 wide was a smidge short for me, and I still wear a 7 1/2 in some shoes. The wide seemed like a normal fit shoe - the regular must be incredibly narrow. Very cute style, good quality, felt comfortable, with even a little bit of arch support. Unfortunately, I did not love how shiny they are. This is a purely subjective personal style thing - this is so close to what I am looking for in an oxford, but I just couldn't do it. If you like shine, though, this seems like a great shoe! But definitely go up a half size, and consider ordering the wide unless your feet are truly narrow.

I ordered these in a half size larger in my usual narrow width. The length was fine as was the width, and they are really cute shoes. I had to return them, though, because they gapped on both side of my foot. I even tried arch supports, but the gaps were still too apparent, so back they go. They are quite stiff, as well. I'm sure if you wore them enough the leather would loosen up, but they would have given me blisters. If you're unsure about the size and can get 1/2 size large, do that. They narrow at the toes, which I think is the issue.

I really wanted shoes of this style. Unfortunately they didn't fit me right. I measure at 11.5 women's with a slightly narrow heel and needing wider toe room. The 12M was too tight in the toe, actually felt short, with a heel that slightly slipped. The 12W had enough toe room but the heel slipped badly. Sigh. I wanted a thin sole with no real arch support, so that part was good.

The many reviews implied that these shoes ran smaller than average, so I ordered a 1/2 size larger and maximum width. These now feel a bit big, but since I wear orthotics, it's going to work. I prefer a lace up shoe as I walk right out of ballet flats all the time, and there wasn't an enormous selection at local shoe NYC stores. I like the styling of this shoe, so I'm overall pleased with the purchase.

I normally wear size 9M. Based on the reviews for this style and my moderate bunions, I was hesitant to order my usual size, so, I ordered size 9.5W. Those were too wide in the heel. I stayed with 9.5 but chose M width instead and that choice was perfect. So, if your feet are normal width and you'd like to wear trouser socks with these, then, I recommend going up 1/2 size and stick with your normal width. These are nice quality leather oxfords, so, they are slightly stiff as expected for fine leather goods. But, they will clearly loosen with wear and the looks are very on trend and flattering for my larger foot!

Really nice shoe; just what I was looking for. Unfortunately too narrow (and I don't have wide feet).

Just the shoe I was looking for. I loved the look and the quality was fine, but they just didn't fit my feet.

Super cute shoe. I have slightly wide foot, size 9 and purchased the wide in a 9.5 because of the mixed sizing reviews. The width just barely worked in the 9.5, but they were slightly too long and bent uncomfortably in the toes when I walked. Definitely true to size length-wise, but I think the width would not have worked in a size 9 because of how the toes tapered. Great quality, but just didn't work for me.

Nice shoes, they go a little too small. The width of M compatible with the description. I recommend !??

This worked well for me. Love the color and style.

I just prefer loafers to oxfords.

Everything ok but not a fit

A beautiful shoe, very well made. Unfortunately even though it was a Wide - D it felt just a bit too tight. I did return these, but they were not available in widest size.

Attractive but very narrow

This shoe would be great in WIDE widths. Otherwise, I really like the shoe.

I have a long, narrow foot but my toes are angled from big to small, not pointed. These remind me of the pointed toe high heels women suffer through. I have a high arch so these just didn't work for me.

The shoe is extremely cute. This unfortunate part is the leather is very stiff. It would crease and hit the top of my foot when I would walk. It unfortunately didn't have enough give to move with my foot.

Bought as gift. Will be returning. Too small and she’s not crazy about the style. Said it felt too flat. No support.

I loved these shoes. They’re so cute. And very comfortable. I loved that they came in wide, which I need because of my bunions. However, there’s no arch support, which I also need because of my pronation, and which means that I wouldn’t be able to wear them for long periods of time. Also, the soles are very slippery, on all surfaces, even carpet, so I’d never be able to walk in them without fear of falling.

I loved the way the shoes looked, as much in reality as on line, but sadly, they were not comfortable. I do have extremely wide feet, but a true double wide usually works, and these did not, even though, following other reviewers' advice, I went up a half size.