Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy XC4 H1 Luxe Hybrid

These shoes really look nice, on par with J&M dress shoes. First time out got a heel blister by hole 9. Hoping they will get better with use. Bought on sale so still consider good value.

Very nice fit. I have a semi-wide foot and the normal width holds firmly.

Very nice shoes. The insole is terrible but shoes themselves are great. Why anyone would claim you can remove the insole and make them wide shoes is be beyond me... It's simply untrue. Regarding the insole: its poorly conceived! It has a seam running through the middle of it that dan be felt while you are wearing the shoes. My recommendation is buy the shoes and throw away the worthless inseams then replace them with good aftermarket ones.

Love styling/material/construction Fit was too narrow

Good shoes

Fit an appearance are very good. I expected the shoe to be more comfortable. Johnson and Murphy needs to upgrade the insole so that the shoe is more comfortable.

These shoes are a little heavy however the fit is good.

Love the shoes, but sole on right foot separated from shoe after a few months of use. Used gorilla glue to reattach. It worked. Still attached after a year of use.

Nice looking shoe. But way to narrow. And I have a narrow foot.

The shoe does not have as much support as I thought it would have. Not completely pleased

First I am a fan of JM shoes. I wore to work everyday and the best shoes I ever had, very comfortable. The golf shoes however with the erc insert was just not what I expected from JM. I don't own a pair of JM golf shoes yet, I had to return to footjoy.

Too big

The style looks great, which is why I ordered the golf shoes. However, the shoes felt uncomfortably narrow/tight. I needed to return the shoes.

I bought this same shoe, same size in white yet the black shoe fit a little snug on my feet. They are not as comfortable.

Shopping on line is challenging for me. I should have went to a retailer so I could see exactly what I would be buying. The product is fine, just not what I expected .

Nice looking shoe, but they do run small. I did remove the first layer of innersole to give me more room and hope that they stretch out some to make more comfortable. I must also wear a thinner sock with these compared to my Foot Joy golf shoes that are a 10W. The bottom innersole is also cut too short not reaching the toe. I play over a 100 rounds of golf a year and have 4 pairs that I rotate. All of my dress and casual shoes are Johnston Murphy so I thought I would give them a try.

I LOVE the shoe. However, the box said 10, but the shoes in the box were 9 1/2. I had to return and wait for second shipment. Can't wait for correct size to get here.

Returned the shoes. One was too tight.

Really did not fit my foot and returned them.

The shoe quality is great. It looks great too. My issue is that I have a half dozen JM different pairs of shoes and they are all size 12. I ordered these in a size 12 too and they run short. I'm am returning this pair and have ordered a size 13 in the same style. You should tell your longtime customers that the sizing runs short compared to your other models. Joe Kane

I loved the look of the shoe, but the neoprene around the ancle and tongue made the shoe hard to put on and did not feel right. Returned them with no problems.

They are decent golf shoes. Nothing special. Works for course, range and clubhouse.

Nice but needs some breaking in before they get comfortable.

Sock inner liner too restrictive. Runs small

The shoe is beautiful, the material and design make it a very nice choice. The only issue I find with the product is that it is extremely narrow. I did remove the insole to make it wider and it fits better however I lost cushion on the palm of my feet and it feels a bit exhausting on long days. I ordered 8 1/2 I did tried on a 9 which felt nicer without removing the insole but the shoe was too long on my toes. I had the same experience with a pair of dress shoes, 9 was a bit too long and 8 1/2 was extremely tight and unbearable for dress shoes, so sadly I ended up returning those. When I saw the HC4 and saw there were water resistant I had to give JM another chance.