Customer Reviews Anodyne No. 19 Casual Mary Jane

Excellent quality but unfortunately not good fit, uncomfortable because heel too flat and not enough arch support

Quality of shoe excellent. Just didn't fit unfortunately.

Awesome Mary Janes! My daughter needed school shoes for her uniform and for dress up and they fit amazingly!! Very well made and worth the price. Come with two different inserts for comfort and height. She is super picky and said immediately how comfortable these shoes are. Very wide feet and these are perfect!

Love these Anodyne Mary Jane shoes. Very cute on my wide feet...Lol I was so happy that extra wide is available. I purchased the black and cognac.

The shoes seem to run narrow But they long velcro strap is perfect for securing my foot with orthotic into the shoe. Typically I weat a 9 medium on my right foot but I had to go up to a 10 wide.

This is my first pair of anodyne shoes and very pleased with comfort and style. The wide shoe box is great for my foot problem

The collar around the ankle is too high putting pressure on my Tarsal Tunnel which makes my feet go to sleep. :(

These shoes are beautiful and well made. They come with two different sets of inserts which is a nice touch. Unfortunately, they were about an inch too long on my feet. I have small, very wide feet and I normally wear running shoes, which tend to run short in length so I order a 7 EE and that fits great. I ordered a 6.5 EE in this shoe and they were an inch too long. The width was about right, so ordering a much smaller size will make them too narrow. If you are sensitive to smells, these are strong smelling out of the box. It was worth a try.

The quality shoe squeaked with my custom AFO inserted. I hate to return, but must.

these shoes were at least a half size too long. I tried to make them fit using the extra insert which did make them tighter but they were still too long, even with socks! I am not going to reorder in a smaller size because the strap is too thin and the weight of the shoe pulls the thin strap down into the top of my foot when taking a step, even when they are fastened loosely; it is very uncomfortable. they ought to make this shoe in an accurate length with a wider and somewhat stretchy strap.

Very comfortable to walk in; but every time I take them off, the Velcro strap rips my knee-length hose.

The straps are freakishly long and drag the ground. The left shoe came with a deep scratch on the top. Despite the extra wide width, the shoe still wasn't wide enough for my bunion. I 'm highly dissatisfied with this purchase.

These shoes are very comfortable right out of the box. They fit my small, wide feet with high instep because the strap is long. Reviews have complained about the strap but it works for my foot. I haven't worn them long because they are my shoes for the Fall. They are a lovely color.

size bigger than normal 10...wider than medium..ok arch support

Very comfortable and light. Only problem was the Velcro on the strap rubbed me at the edges so I took a Dremel and ground the edges back and now its less irritating.

The shoes were fine and comfy, but the color was way too orange for my taste. I was hoping for a more brown pair. The pic in the description does show as orangish, and that is accurate.

As soon as I put these on, I was amazed at how comfortable they were. I love that the Velcro closure goes far enough along the strap to actually be adjustable, unlike other brands. I do wish the strap was a little less thick as it seems to stick up a bit much but that doesn’t take away from the comfort of the shoe. The width was perfect (I have a short, very wide foot). Unfortunately, they were way too long…they seem to run a size+ larger. I like to have a bit of extra room in the toe area but these were about an inch too long. I’m exchanging for a smaller size because I liked them so much.

This shoe seems like it might run a bit large. I could fit my entire hand in the back of the shoe, so there was no way I could walk in them without purchasing some inserts which usually turns out to be a HIT or MISS adventure!

The color is labeled as cognac but it is really a dark orange so the description is a little misleading. These shoes barely meet my needs but I could not find any alternatives from Dansko or Munro, shoes I really like better. I think by purchasing drug store inserts I can improve both the fit and the arch support so I decided to keep this pair. The color is disappointing because I thought it would be more brown than orange but the color is not bad for fall and the shoes look fine with the pants I will be wearing them with so I decided NOT to return the shoes. I however will probably not order other shoes from this company in the future. The shoes do have a nice comfortable foot bed and look "cute" with the pants I bought them for. Also the heel height is perfect and I love the velcro strap. Very few shoes are perfect so I decided that I would keep these and modify the arch problem which may help with slightly increased width issue as well.

The shoe is no where near the size I ordered. It's HUGE!

THIS PAIR OF SHOES CAME WITHOUT INSOLES??????

I have hard to fit feet and wear custom orthotics but they just weren't comfortable in this shoe. There seemed to be too much space between my foot and the top of the shoe, even with a smaller insert under my orthotic and the strap pulled down.

Item is not as pictured. Black shoe does not have white contrast stitching.

These shoes are so comfortable, and they are so nice looking! I love them.

I have trouble with shoe sizing sometimes I am 11 WW other times 12 WW. I sent these 12 @@ back and bought the 11WW which are just fine.