Customer Reviews Anodyne No. 12 Casual Oxford

The size fit and felt okay. The leather looked as if it was fake or less than real leather. It would work for some people but did not have the style or look that I wanted.

The fit is great. Very comfortable and support seems good. Conservative styling. I’ll see how they hold up. Shoe horn and extra foam inserts included.

Love the quality and style of this shoe. I have bought it several times but have returned it each time because I can't seem to nail down the size I need. Normally need a wide because of the toe box, but the wide and extra wide are just what they say including in the heel area. Believe I know what size to get now, but 11 and 1/2 wide seems to be perpetually sold out. Great shoe though once you figure out your size.

The fit and size were good. The shoe is comfortable to wear and the quality of leather finish flawless. The sole is plastic and slightly flexible so while walking so the shoe can bend yet still supports the foot. Around the heel was slightly too lose for my fit, so the shoe lifted a bit, but the manufactuer included additional foam inserts you could place on top of the in-built arch support to raise your foot up. The foam inserts solved the lose fitting heel enough to be just fine to wear by raising my foot closer to the upper leather and heel. The toe box was comfortable for both my feet, one foot being slightly wider and shorter and the other foot narrrower and longer. There was enough space to accommodate the variation in size. The manufactuer included a light weight plastic shoe horn and a plastic shoe bag (at least I can only think that is what it is intended for). For the money the shoe appears to be well made and I look forward to wearing them.

Because I neglected to check whether the shoe was mens and I need a womens shoe, it was not a correct fit. I am returning the shoe. My apology.

The shoes are very light and comfortable. I have wide feet and the fit is great.

Very confortable, what I was looking.

The shoes are great! Well made and light - you don’t feel like you’re dragging around two fifty pound weights. Unfortunately, my feet are the problem. I need a wide shoe and it seems I need a half size. I tried a 13W and it was too loose. I tried a 12W and it was too tight. Unfortunately, this shoe, and many others, don’t come in a 121/2 W.

I purchased the shoes in size 8 4E. The toe box felt narrower than my other 4Es. Attractive shoe, but the leather seems to scratch easily. Kind of like the leather in Top Siders. There were scratches near the back, either from shipping or from some previous customer trying them on. With a neuroma in my right foot, I absolutely need a wide toe box, so these were returned.

Nice shoes for my husband for our wedding. They’re comfortable and stylish but could be a little more “sleek”.

Shoe feels HEAVY size too big. First time I ordered wide and was disappointed with the fit

This is terrible quality. The tred seems like it is plastic and is no way worth the cost!