Customer Reviews Kelsi Dagger Brooklyn Island

I get more compliments on these boots than any boots I’ve never had. I bought the light brown. Now I need black and brown and they are sold out. I have a wider foot but not wide. And high arch. The ball of my foot never hurts. Never a blister. LOVE!!!!!!!

The color is not as green as it appeared on my screen. It is a dark gray w a green hue, which is very beautiful and IMO a more versatile color

1. How are Zappos customer service representatives always so nice??? What are they feeding them and how do I get some. 2. The boots are beautiful but even the wide is too narrow and my feet are not very wide at all! Very upsetting.

Oh my. These are so comfortable. I wore them all day at my school and had no issues. Happy feet, happy me.

Nice leather, and inside footbed padding. I had to size up 1/2 size.

These were just delivered. As it is 90 degrees, I only wore them around the house. But I'm in love with these boots. Buttery soft leather, padded insole, beautiful color for the fall. I ordered the wide, and they fit perfect with a thin sock. Definitely could not have squeezed my foot into the regular width, as I can with other brands.

Actually super comfortable, and these days comfort is very important to me as much as fashion. They look really cute on too!!

Great fit, comfortable to walk in and I love the look.

Love the fit, they are comfortable and I love the style.

These are fantastic and incredibly comfortable! I had extensive foot surgery 4 months ago and, although I won't be ready to wear these for 8 hours at a time, I do feel that they are comfortable enough to wear all day under normal circumstances. I appreciate that this manufacturer focused on comfort in addition to making a great looking boot!

Very Cute, fit perfect. Leather is a beautiful and soft. Thanks for the wide.

beautiful boot and comfortable. i did not size up, but I could see if you want to wear thick socks, you might want to go up a half size.

Love these boots! I did have to size up half a size to get them perfect, but it's well worth it. They look especially great with long dresses and cropped, flared jeans but are really versatile. Also comfortable - just the right heel height and feel stable. Suede is very soft. All around a great boot and I definitely recommend them!

This is a beautiful boot. I was so happy upon receiving them to find they were exactly as pictured; the leather is gorgeous and the cushion inside feels super luxurious. However after wearing them just one time, the sole started to wear down on the heel. I've since worn the boots only two or three times, and the sole is shaving off rapidly. I'm used to paying more for shoes in general, because it's hard to find them in a wider size, and I'd also much rather get shoes that will last rather than throw money at cheaper ones that fall apart right away. I really wish the quality of the soles on these matched that of the leather upper, but unfortunately they are wearing like $20 shoes instead of $200. So disappointing, because they are otherwise just lovely. As far as fit, I ordered an 8W and they are still slightly snug in the toe box, but otherwise true to size (and I have really wide feet).

I'm a 10W, sometimes can fit into a 10.5. These were very cramped in a 10W in both length and width. I sent them back without hesitation. An 11M is usually too big for me, but I'm debating re-ordering in an 11W. I color was more orange than caramel -- if I reorder, I'd get it in black. The leather felt thin but at least I know it would stretch.

The fit was true to size - I purchased a WIDE (thank you for offering this!) and love it. I did go up 1/2 a size to 7.5W since I wanted to use orthotics. However, the right boot had a quarter-size light spot on top of the boot which is why I need to return it. I hope there's another pair.

I had to return them because the suede in the back was flapping over and falling down because the zippier only goes up halfway. They were TTS and very comfortable. I loved the look but couldn’t deal with the one flap that kept folding over.

Sizing ratings do not apply here since Zappos sent me the entirely wrong boot. Like, entirely. Not even close. Wrong style, wrong size, could not be more wrong. I ordered a cute leather bootie (and pretty splurgy, too) and they sent the clunkiest winter snow boot ever made. Aaaaaand now my size is sold out in the boot I *actually* ordered. Not happy.

The zipper is broken on one of the boots and the leather is damaged.