Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Christy

Left shoe is defective right at the front, for like a scratch at the "round" toe that seems a bad cut.

I bought this item a week ago and got a left shoe defective with a bad cut that caused the effect of a square toe... and the right is as expected a round toe.

I love the look of these shoes but even after I sized down they are too big. They are too long and give me bad blisters. Super cute though!!

Absolutely gorgeous shoe! Just the style I wanted but could not find the right fit. I usually wear a 7.5 or 8. I purchased at 7.5. It was much too long and already pretty snug on the width. I wanted these shoes to work so badly, so I exchanged the 7.5 for a 7. The length was good but the width was uncomfortably narrow. I sent the 7 back too. I would think for this price, the manufacturer would offer wide width. Additionally, this is a very stiff and heavy shoe. You might have to suffer through some blisters before they are broken in.

item was used with a foreign shoe insert in it. SO DISGUSTED

Had to return twice. The first pair came with a defect and when I received the second pair, the right shoe was bigger than the left shoe.

I bought these for work 2 weeks ago. I want to preface this, with that I have never written a review before. I am incredibly disappointed by these loafers. They are the most uncomfortable shoes I have ever worn. It has been 8 days since I wore these shoes for the first time, and I am STILL bleeding. I had bloody blisters after wearing these shoes for only 30 minutes. I still am unhealed and can't return the shoes. I own multiple shoes from Sam Edelman and am so upset, I haven't been able to wear shoes that touch my heel since. DO NOT BUY.

Slightly narrow but fit in the length. I was so disappointed with these shoes. When I first received them, they had scuff marks all over them. They also looked worn with wrinkle marks on the shoes. I called customer service and they return the shoes. When the second pair of shoes came, they still had some marks and wrinkles on them. If you really want these shoes I would recommend getting them in black. I am very disappointed in SE!!! I expect higher quality shoes!

When I wear socks, this pair of shoes doesnt stay on my feet. Its really disappointing but I have to exert extra energy when walking because the heels keep falling off given the lack of friction. Didnt expect this and suggest you look into options if you want to buy.

An absolute waste of money. I was so excited to find these because they fell perfectly within my office's dress code. But they are incredibly uncomfortable and constantly slip off my heels even through they fit snugly to the size of my feet. No matter what socks I wear, I tried multiples i own and purchased three other kinds, they constantly slip off and have made wearing them such a misery. Only have worn them twice and wish I could return them asap.

I just purchased within the last two weeks and I have worn twice thinking the size was ok however they keep growing on me. Now they slip off my heel and I love the shoe just to big and not a true fit. Crazy waste of money.

Like the design. But the upper material makes noise and gives me blister at forefoot.

I can't explain it, it does not fit. It's Pretty cute though.

Very cheap plastic material and look, uncomfortable.

Shipping took foreeeeeverr! The loafers are cute, but very narrow, and I think the pair I received was a bad batch. The outline at the front of the left shoe was very crooked and the glue between the sole and the shoe was pulling apart on one shoe when i tried it on. I will be returning and trying another style.

Super tight shoes! I am going to return both shoes I purchased!

Only tried these on once and there's already a crease in the shoes. For this price, they should be able to hold their shape a bit better. Seems like low grade leather.