Customer Reviews L.L.Bean Scotch Plaid Shirt

I was disappointed with the quality of the flannel fabric. It is much thinner than the same shirt I bought a year ago. I wouldn't recommend this shirt if you want a real flannel one.

Nice shirt! Surprised to find out it was made in Sri Lanka! A little bummed that a button fell off immediately while trying it on. Would have given it 4 stars if that hadn't happened.

Have a number of these shirts. Current selection muted blue Buchanan is really darker than online ( online colors always a problem)' I'll be keeping it but it's not a nice color! Too dark mostly green/brown. Should have gotten the green one!

I was very happy about the colors and tailoring. But the quality of the material was already piling out of the dryer on the first and second wash, so far.

Shirt was good quality, fit well and looked neat and trim

Ordered the BlueRidge, totally love the colors and pattern

It's a gift for later. So I can't answer most questions. You too often want answers where info is not yet available.

after only one washing this shirt is all pilly and worn looking

I returned the size 1X shirt because the sleeves were way too short for me. Otherwise the shirt seemed nice.

Heavier fabric than you used to sell for women's flannel shirts. Washed it on cold dried it on cooler cycle still shrank. If I had known it would do that I would have ordered a larger size.

Unfortunately it was a gift and was returned as the fit was not right although the size was similar to sizes that were previously recently worn by the recipient.

This is a nice shirt overall. The sleeves always shrink after the first wash with LL Bean flannels, so they always land above my wrist. If you're tall keep that in mind. The quality isn't what it used to be. The other pattern of this that I bought had a pull in the fabric across the front, so I don't wear it. That one makes it look like a used thrifted shirt. I do wish there were more colors available and my size wasn't sold out in some of them.

Nice plaid pattern, soft flannel, but it runs small. I had to size up from medium to large.

Same great quality as other flannels in this line. However, the color is awful! I returned it.

sz14, 5'2. Nice shirt, but L (recommended) was tight through the back and sleeves seemed narrow.

I'm not happy about how the hem at the back curls up. The directions say do not iron. What should I do about it?

Love the feel and colors of this flannel shirt. I ordered up so the top would be roomy, good thing I did because I find the top runs on the smaller side

Not sure what is the problem with the fabric, but it does tend to pill and look wrinkled after very few washes. After buying three last year and having that issue, I decided this year to order another since I love the color options and how they look when you first get them. However, I only wear them as shackets over a t-shirt now, so I won't have to wash as often.

Love the colors and the fit is good. The flannel, on the other hand, needs an upgrade. It's soft, which is nice, but too thin. It's already piling and I've only washed it 2-3 times.

I have two others of this shirt in significantly different colors. I thought the "indigo" with some cream and tan in it, would offer some nice variety. Unfortunately, seems that they're trying to cut costs and cutting the fabric a little smaller than previously. The other two tartans that I have, same size, petite/small, are indeed relaxed fit. This one I felt like I was stuffed into a sausage skin. Upon comparing the shirts, literally back to back, the back was narrower, the two front halves were each a little narrower, the armhole was significantly smaller. Sadly, returning.

I love the plaid and the quality of the material. However, one sleeve seems to be more snug than the other; so I can't layer over a long sleeve tee. I can wear over a tank, but that does limit my options.

I cannot stand the razor sharp label on the neck. Why can't you use COTTON thread/tags instead of the cutting rough material on the label of ALL your clothing !! It is extremely uncomfortable -- but if i cut it out it leaves a gapping hole that i need to sew back together. PLEASE stop using these horrible tags!

Soft fabric and comfortable. A little too big. I havent worn it yet cause It doesn't look good. Maybe when i need to wear more layers.

The colors were less bright in person, so I returned it.

Loved the color way and bought this thinking I was investing in a quality flannel. Unfortunately, after one wash the fabric is fuzzy and pilling. It also shrank quite a bit - washed cold, dried extra low. I got a petite small. I'm 5' 1" - after washing the sleeves now ride up 2 inches above my wrist with arms extended. Doesn't bother me, but something to note.