Customer Reviews L.L.Bean Scotch Plaid Shirt

Love the colors of my new flannel shirt. Goes with several of my T-shirts but I am disappointed in the quality of the flannel itself. After just a coupe of washings in cold water it it is starting to pill.

Very nice shirt. Nice flannel weight. The petite size is ok but the sleeves are long and have to be folded up. Works as a stand alone or over t shirts. The relaxed fit is comfy.

I have a closet full of Bean flannel shirts This Buchanan plaid called out "one more." I appreciate the way the seams match the plaid. And, YAY, no blazen logos stitched to the front of the shirt.

Nice shirt colors; nice fabric. Good fit except for long sleeves

Beautiful colors. Fabric too thin. Slightly oversized for layering.

Flannel fabric appears to be piling already. Very comfortable and true to size. Great color, coordinates with many colors. Love it.

Soft, easy care, durable fabric and quality construction. Sleeves aren't too tight or too loose. Especially appreciate the button on the sleave placket so sleeves stay rolled up. At 5'5", 135 lbs, 37.5" chest, no waist, slender frame the medium is a little big in neck and shoulders, but currently need the extra room around the middle - thank goodness for relaxed fit!

I have several of the Scotch Plaid flannel shirts, and a few years ago a Slightly Fitted option was also offered. Those fit better than the Relaxed version imo even if you have a straight figure as I do. I now see an oversized Boyfriend option has been added. Please also add the Slightly Fitted option again, as it looked a little more feminine and is less bulky. It still had plenty of room at the waist even for those of us without much waistline; it wasn't totally fitted nor snug anywhere. It gave an illusion of having a waistline while still being roomy enough and very comfortable. The Relaxed version is very boxy and shapeless even though it's true to size in the bust. I haven't bought this year's new patterns but I like all the ones I have and they still look good. The flannel is probably mid weight, not heavy weight, and the colors are beautiful. On the ones I have there is a second button at the cuffs which really helps those of us with small wrists. It's an added touch that makes a difference. Also, thank you for offering a good selection in Petites. Some reviews mention a recent lowering of quality. Please don't do that! I love my old Scotch Plaid flannel shirts from LLB. Just wish the Slightly Fitted option was still available.

I just bought this flannel shirt in the Antique Royal Stewart but the colors are too faded so I am returning it and buying it in the Navy Stewart which is a more vibrant color which I like to wear in winter. I buy these flannel shirts in L and wear them all winter as a jacket over my waffle shirts. They are a perfect weight and so soft. The color is the only reason for a 4 rating.

Very soft nice material, ordered one size up for roomier fit. But WHY the scratchy tag? I tried to cut it off but that made it worse, from the itchy remnants. You ruined a great shirt with that tag.

Comfy but a tad itchy. Runs VERY large. Very easily styled.

Plaid is great with my golden yellow long sleeve t's or turtles. Fabric is nice but a bit lightweight. This specific item the plaids actually match which is surprising but appreciated.

I have LLBean flannel shirt that is five years old and still great. This is one of two new ones for me this winter. I like to layer with LLBean cotton tees. Perfect for winter warmth!

These flannels are very soft and moderately warm. Great for layering on a cool Fall day. My only issue is they pill and shed all over the place. I don't wear too often because of that.

This is a nice light to medium weight shirt. The color matches the pictures. I just think for the price, their plaids should match, but I suppose those days are gone.

Fits well and great workmanship. The arm length IS NOT GORILLA length. I would have liked more classic, conservative plaids. My style is very traditional. In the past you had more for me to choose from. Also, in the past your flannel was a little heavier which I prefer. Now it is too thin.

My 8 year old fleece is finally starting to wear out so I purchased this as a replacement. It's warm and comfortable. Really nice fleece. It does shrink up in the dryer so beware if you on in between sizes. Would be more comfortable if I had sized up.

I love LL Bean relaxed fit flannel shirts. I have several. I've noticed an inconsistency in the sizing though, sometimes depending on the pattern. A new thing is the arms have gotten tighter. LLBean, please realize that some women have muscles, not twig arms.

I've been wearing shirts from L.L. Bean for 30 years. I've wanted one that is simply browns and white since I wore my old one out years ago. This is the first one I've found. The one I ordered is a medium (10-12) and is a bit smaller than ones I've had in the past. It fits but the sleeves barely reach my wrists. This one felt thin when I opened the box but after washing is a lovely soft shirt. It's not a heavy flannel and will be great for these autumn days.

Very nice shirt, light weight for fall and to wear over a t-shirt. Only problem is the sleeves are always too long by an inch or two.

I always love to have a flannel shirt in my closet and have been buying these for many years. The shirt lasts but I look for a different plaid every few years. I do think the flannel has become thinner over the years. Be forewarned the shirts do shrink when washed and dried. Since I'm not one for ironing, I do put them in the dryer. With that in mind I now buy two sizes up. Still think these shirts are the best on the market.

Loved the look of this shirt in the catalog and thought the colors would work well for me for Fall. It fit well, hung right and is well made. I am returning it as the colors, although I like them, don't look good on me. I have other LL Bean flannel shirts and they never wear out! I would buy again just a different color.

Loved the deep colors. Arrived quickly also and loved the price.

I do like this color, and even though the body of the shirt is longer than in the past I like the length. The sleeves come down to my finger tips and sleeves are wider which I can live with as I roll them up. However, I wanted the same weight fabric for warmth, and what I received was much thinner (not see through). I was disappointed after comparing the new shirt to my 3 thicker flannels from years ago. Yesterday I wore the new shirt in low 60 degree weather and was comfortable. I decided to keep it, well, for now, not sure how this will wash, dry, will it pill? The label says 'all cotton' but it's not the same. If this one works out well that would be great, having my first lighter weight flannel! BTW, the size is women's 2X.

Beautiful color. Would have given 5 stars but tag says do not iron; shirt really needs ironing. fit is great