Customer Reviews Madewell The Corinne Lugsole Loafer

great shoe! fits perfectly. I usually wear an 8 but this 7.5 is perfect. WEll made, classy, exactly what i wanted

I was able to wear them RIGHT out of the box. Construction, quality - great. I might buy the black ones!

too small, wish i had ordered 1/2 size bigger but was sold out.

These loafers run slightly narrow. I’m typically a 6.5/7. But I needed a 7.5 in these. Cute and comfortable in the next size up.

These shoes look very well-made. The camel color is very nice for Fall and winter. The thing I didn't like is they don't seem to have good arch support.

Comfortable and attractive. A good "office" shoe.

Unfortunately, the toe area was quite narrow and the heel area stretched out immediately and my feet kept slipping out of them. Nice shoes, so I’m sad to have to return them.

It is a beautiful show but stiff and narrow. I was worried that it might be uncomfortable so I ordered a slightly larger size and made it through the work day! Not the most comforatble shoe but super cute for the office.

Very nice shoe, but was too tight with my custom arch supports.

These shoes are really heavy so I sent them back.

I wanted to love them. I think the style is one of the best out there. They are just too stiff and are going to require a lot of work to break them in. When you pay over $150 for shoes, you expect they will be comfortable. Sadly I'm sending them back.

Loved the style, may have been a tad too tight if I wore with socks I'd go size up. The main issue was they were squeeky when I walked, not sure if that would have eventually gone away but for the price did not want to risk it.

Fit a bit narrow for my comfort

I really wanted to like these, since they look great, but they did not fit well. Too narrow in the ball and toe, but oddly too wide in the heel. Both the upper and the sole are quite stiff, so I didn't have any hope that they would eventually stretch out or break in. The color is excellent though.

Beautiful shoes, and well made! BUT narrow! The length was ok, but just no side to side toe room and super tight around the midfoot. Sadly there was just no way it was going to work for me, and I have normal width feet.

I love these shoes, very modern, comfortable, and up-to-date. But I have narrow feet, and these shoes feel wider than usual in the heel--my heel slips out when walking. I'll probably compensate by wearing thick sock because I like them so much, and a smaller size would be too short.

Loved the look. Nice leather. Great style. I really liked the lug sole for traction, non slip. Fit was pretty good on left foot except my heel slipped out at bit. I could have adjusted for this with an insert. They did not fit my right foot which I use an orthotic for, otherwise I would have kept them.

These incredibly cute shoes seem true to size however, they are very uncomfortable. Walking in the shoes about 150 feet caused raging blisters on my inner foot by the big toe. I do not normally get blisters from shoes and not normally there! They are so cute that I am keeping them, but I have to preventatively apply Band-Aids on both feet in that location and make sure I am going somewhere that does not require a lot of walking. As expensive as they are, I probably wouldn’t buy them again knowing what I know now which is too bad because they are darn cute.

Fit was fine but I was disappointed with the color and finish of the leather. In the picture it looks richer and more lustrous but the pair I received was lighter in color and "flat"--looked like fake leather.

Love the way these look, but the fit was very off. I have a pretty narrow foot and these 8s were way too narrow for me. I usually wear an 8, sometimes a 7.5, and these were so narrow I could tell immediately, even with wear, they'd be tight and uncomfortable. Then oddly, they are very long. A good 2 inches past my toes, and oddly a space behind my heel, but a half size smaller would be too small to get my foot into width-wise. Not sure why they decided to build a shoe like this!

Loved the look of these shoes, but they just weren't comfortable. Ordered a 1/2 size up after reading other reviews and because my regular size 8 was not in stock, but they were too narrow.

Way too big.

These look so cool, and I wanted to love them, but after a couple of months of insane discomfort and no sign of them breaking in, I finally had to send them to the thrift store. I tried shoe stretchers, etc and I could never get these to feel good—by the end of a relatively sedentary work day I was always in excruciating pain. I have fairly narrow feet, so I don’t think a wider width was the issue. :(

I really wanted to love these but they were just too tight and narrow across the top of my foot and my toe area, and I don't have wide feet. I wish they fit more comfortably because they're really cute.

My stars reflect the fact that these shoes run big. I could not get a feel for comfort or overall value. Nice material and style.