Customer Reviews Trotters Kari

While I say this shoe is true to size, based upon reviews, I ordered a 1/2 size smaller than my normal size 9W and they fit perfectly. This shoe is very cushiony, comfortable & smart looking. My only concern is that if the heel loosens up the slightest, I won't be able to keep it on my foot.. a problem when you have a wide foot & a narrow heel. I'll need to wear them around the house a bit more to determine if I'm going to keep or return them.... however I would still recommend this shoe.

So disappointed even in a N, they didn't fit my skinny foot. Really cute and comfortable.

Had to return the size 9 W shoes I originally ordered to purchase 8.5 Ws, as the 9s were clearly too long for my usually 9 / 9.5 feet. The 8.5s felt very tight around the toes at first, but adjusted to a comfortable fit within 3 days of wearing. My left foot tends to slip out of the heel of whatever dress shoe I'm wearing, and these are no exception, despite the smaller size.

Actually, these shoes are not grey - they are sliver. This was unexpected. I ordered them for my business suits, so now not sure I should keep them now, not a very business color. Other than that, shoes are good, fit and feel as expected.

I have ordered several pair of black dressy pumps these finally fit IF you take out the extra inset which is unnecessary. The remaining footbed is finished and padded normally. I don’t understand the need for the insert and it makes the shoe too small. I would have liked a more sculpted heel but these are ok and comfortable for a cocktail party/dancing evening. UPS will probably be surprised I stopped returning Zappos boxes

These are nice looking shoes. Unfortunately, they felt narrower than any other of my shoes. I have a medium to wide foot so these shoes should fit a person that has a medium or medium to narrow foot. They were returned.

This is a nice looking shoe. The size what right, but the width was a little snug. If I went a half size larger, the shoe would have been too long. They are being returned.

Love the style of the shoe except the heel is to clunky, it is even hard to take a step. It also ruins the look of the shoe. I ordered back also but wore before I realized the problem.

Good quality

Nice shoes. I wish I could have kept them the the heel is way too wide. Even with heel grips inserted my heel came out of the shoe when I walked.

Had to return them due to being too big. Wanted to exchange for smaller size and I am waiting for them to be restocked.

Very comfortable. Shoe had more of almond/rounded toe - rather than a pointy toe. Wish it would have gone with my dress.

Liked the style. 8 1/2 is too big.

For a narrow, the heel was loose. I walked right out of them and had to return them.

I have worn Trotters for years but this was at least a full size smaller and narrower than usual. Sending them back.

The sides looked worn in several places. I like the shoes, so sending these back and will order new ones.

I really wanted to keep these shoes as the heel height was perfect. Unfortunately they are falling off my feet. So I must return them. If you order, please order 1/2 size smaller than you normally do.

This was at least half a size if not a full size too small. I have several pairs of Trotters and the last few I have ordered were far too small. I dont know why they suddenly have such a size difference and my feet are size 12 so I cant get a larger size. No longer a go to brand for me!

Length felt true to size, but the toe box was far too tight. Alas, my search for a comfortable pump continues.

I usually wear a nine med. but they were too short so I ordered a 9.5 med. and the length is good but the heel is wide. I'm keeping them and put a stick on heel pad in the back and hope this will work ok. Not crazy about having to do that for shoes that cost over $100.

I like the shoes but they are much too wide for my foot. I will have to return since I ordered a N and you don;t have them in slim or extra narrow

I love the shoes, but they squeak! I read another review that stated this, purchased them hoping they would not and I was so disappointed!! They squeak!!!! I returned 2 pairs because of this only. I purchased another Trotter shoe that did not squeak! Beyond that...Trotters shoes are the best for me!

Purchased a 9. Will return and purchase a 81/2.