Customer Reviews Trotters Harlowe

These are comfy and roomy, but they are very deep and styled like a loafer since the top comes up quite high on the foot. Also because of my foot shape I thought the very back might give me a blister. If you prefer the low toe look, this is probably not the loafer style to try. They were nice, just not my style once I tried them on.

Way too wide for my foot-returned

The actual color of the shoe is much lighter than the online picture suggests. I was looking for a brown flat and this is tan.

I have purchased about 5 pairs of trotters, all size 9. These ones were falling off my feet at work. I was embarrassed.

This size was too tight at the toe area…..I should have sized up to a 9. The left shoe was wider than the right for some reason. By sizing up the heal would be too loose on me. I had to return. The style is really pretty but just didn’t work for me.

These were a little tight in the front and loose near the arches. The "leather?" looked more like plastic.

I love this brand of shoes, but these MUST be mismarked! They are SO narrow! The style is perfect, but i cannot wear them.

Didn’t like the patent leather

Very narrow, must return!

The toe box was too small.

I ordered a wide and the shoe is extremely narrow. Narrower than a normal width. I will have to return it.

I have a bunion so always need a wide size. I'm typically a size 7 or 7.5. I bought both sizes in a wide and the whole shoe was wide, just gaping all around the entire foot. When I took a step and my foot would land, you could see the shoe gap at the arch and on the outer edge of my foot. It made the shoe look cheap and sloppy. Otherwise the style is elegant.

The shoes wore out pretty quickly. The leather was cheap, the leather at the toe box began peeling after the first wear and the sole quickly began separating from the upper.

I wanted to love these shoes, I think a little too much. The color was perfect, the style was perfect; they were going to be my new "go to" shoes for the summer. And then they arrived. I have a wide foot, so I tried a wide and double wide. The double wide gapped on the side. I tried the wide, and they were too narrow. Everything was returned.

I loved the look of these, but I could not wear them. They were narrower than expected (I ordered the wide), and very firm. Loved the look but ... ouch.

This shoe is beautiful BUT the fit is very odd. Too large and too small at the same time. I ordered a 10W which is my usual size in other brands like Naturalizer. My toes hit the pointed angles at the front of the shoe but the rest of the shoe was too large (too wide and too long). I have wide feet and don't often say that a shoe is too wide for me. I don't think there is any way a different size would fit. Had to return.

This shoe was very narrow in the toe box, more so than other pointy shoes that I own. I felt I would have needed a larger size due to that but then the larger size would have slipped on my heel. I didn't like it enough to exchange for a different size. Footbed felt comfortable but didn't do much walking around due to the toe box issues.

Bad quality. Falling apart very quickly. Looks cheap.

I am very disappointed; the ‘Wide’ feels more like a ‘B’ width. I generally wear a 8.5 W, but had to return them and purchasd the 9 W which fits somewhat better, but because it is too large, the shoe ‘puckers’. One return is enough, I will have to make these work. No complaints about Zappos Customer Service or Return Policy! Unfortunately I could not find a shoe locally and had to look online and now I own a marginally satisfying product. The shoe is more stylish than most ‘comfortable walking shoes’.

I bought these shoes because I needed the color pink that they come in and Trotter's narrow shoes have always worked well for me. I wore them to a graduation and I was miserable. I ended up with blisters on both heels and the arch support was not there. I wish I hadn't worn them because now I am stuck with them.

Very disappointing shoe. Looked chic and well made in the photograph but it looked stodgy on the foot. Also someone had obviously previously tried and returned them and Zappo's hadn't bothered to repack professionally before sending on to me.

Agree with prior reviews. The style is fabulous but the shoe is too wide and looks awkward with walking.