Customer Reviews Trotters Harlowe

A little bit tight when I took them out of the box, but I took a chance they would stretch and it didn’t take long during my first wear for them to fit very comfortably. I’m a standard 10 but with narrow tip shoes I sometimes take 10.5. I found these to be extremely comfortable - I have nerve damage in the balls of my feet and I am very particular about shoes.

Too narrow in the toe box, though perfect in the heel. Precious little arch support.

First bought these in black. LOVED them. Once I had them on my feet, I went back to Zappos to order one in every color! These are the most comfortable flats I’ve ever worn—and I have a bunch Frye’s (which are comfy as well). The arch support is fantastic. I typically wear a 9.5 or a 10, but the 9.5 fits like a glove without any need to “wear them in”. Dying to get the blue ones!!

These were THE ONES, until I wore them around inside for an hour....then the back of my heel at the top of the shoe, screamed at me. I thought maybe a little time would take care of it. Nope...tried for a few days and then found out my 30 year old daughter was having the exact same issue. I am SO disappointed because EVERYTHING else about this cute shoe was awesome. Trotters, you nearly had it!!

My feet seem to have been shrinking. I've gone from 6.5-7, to 6-6.5 and its hard to know through online purchase which will work for different styles. Since this is a "leaner" type shoe, the 6 was too small even though another type of shoe, I wore a 6. Thank God for Zappos easy and fast ordering and returning and re-ordering policies. The 6 was way to tight and small but the 6.5 is perfect. I do have a big toe joint issue on my left foot so it complicates matters even more but these work great! I may splurge and purchase another color. Thank you, Zappos for making the process of online ordering of shoes SO easy!

These shoes are so narrow. I’m well aware that I don’t have narrow feet but I can wear non-wide specific shoes. I could barely get my feet in these!

Wow! Ran very large.

I have very wide feet and have difficulty finding comfortable shoes. I purchased WW and they are the perfect width. I wear them almost every day to the office, as they are so comfortable. I bought another pair in a different color too.

Attractive shoe but they rub the back of my ankles (with trouser socks on) and the pointed toe does not leave enough room for my toes without squishing them!

Wanted blue shoes, Old lady-ish, and although double wide, the shape was too narrow, just on the right big toe.

This shoe is too pointed for me to wear. Toe is very narrow and my foot isn't

This shoe looks sleek and stylish, but it just didn't fit my feet very well. I got the wide width, and it almost felt a little too wide yet my toes felt rather squished by the pointy toe of the shoe. Pointed toe shoes usually are fine for me, so I don't know why these weren't comfortable. They also gapped a lot around my foot as I walked, and felt like they would fall off once they broke in. This may be a case of wrong size/width, but I just can't bring myself to order 5 pairs of shoes to find one that fits, even with free shipping! These are going back.

Oh this shoe. So pretty right out of the box in the tan color. Very nice looking for work. However, I put it on and I could tell that the upper wasn't as giving/forgiving as I had hoped. It's a tight shoe for a narrow foot. I have medium width feet but the pointy toe box was crunching my poor piggies. It has a moderate amount of cushion in the foot bed, so if you have a slim foot and want to look snazzy in the office. These should be good for you.

Love these shoes- stylish and comfortable for my wide feet. Only 3 stars because they did not wear well- the leather is super soft and has numerous tears after only 1 season of wear.

I love these shoes, but they gap on both sides when I walk. I ordered a wide, like I normally do, and they did fit across the widest part of my feet, but in the middle section of each shoe, they were just too wide.

Was really disappointed with these considering the price. Regular width tends to be too narrow for me while wide-width is usually way too wide. I got these is wide-with and they feel like I ordered narrow. Super tight and even after wearing many times at work (hoping they’d widen) they are still too tight. Also, the sole and heel are very thin which makes me feel like they wouldn’t last long even if they did fit. Will never buy this brand again.

I was so disappointed in the discomfort of these shoes as they are super pretty and stylish. However, I didn’t even take a single step in them. The heal was the most uncomfortable part where they hurt the moment I put them on. I considered buying heal pads but the rest of the leather shoe was so stiff I would imagine they would have been too uncomfortable for my short walk to work even. Returning.

I've been looking for a good flat to kick around in for awhile now, and these are...just OK. I am a solid size 10.5, but with these had to go up to an 11. Even with that the toe box area is tight and uncomfortable, yet the sides bow out and make your foot look wider. Perhaps if I'd bought an 11 N it would look better. Have worn about 6 times, and am still trying to break in the toe area which isn't super comfortable. I'm still on the lookout for that perfect flat.

I really wanted to love these shoes. They were just what I was looking for. However the fit was off for my foot. The wide width fit comfortably in the toe box, but was too wide mid-foot, causing visible gapping. Will try more Trotters, they seem very well made.

Nope. I ordered two pairs of these and would return both if the dog hadn't chewed one before I could wear it. Wanted a basic flat...there's something just dowdy about these...hard to pin down. They are a little wide which makes them look sort of chubby rather than sleek and professional. I have narrow feet but these look plump on me.

I wanted to love these. So comfortable, didn't rub, and I never got blisters wearing these. However, they make my feet sweat. Like out of control. Like sliding around in the shoe. For being leather I was pretty surprised. And now disappointed because I wore these out of the house and can't return them, but they're unwearable because of the sweating.

Ouch! These felt very snug. I wear a size 7 and these felt tight going on and snug all around. I do not have narrow feet nor do I have wide feet. But, I am not willing to go through a lot of discomfort hoping they will stretch to a comfortable level. Sorry, these are going back.

These myst not have had any quality control. They arrived misshapen and completely unwearable.

ONE FIT THE OTHER SHOE WAS SMALLER BOTH WERE MARKED SAME SIZE. LOUSY MANUFACTURING AND QUALITY CONTROL. THESE ARE GOING BACK. One shoe fit well if a little loose. No rub on heel and length was fine. The other shoe was higher on heel and rubbed and narrower. very uncomfortable. What is happening to all these companies that used to make great shoes and now its robotic overseas garbage!!! Bring quality back!

THESE ARE THE WORST SHOES EVER!! I WORE THEM ONCE, WITH BANDAIDS, AND THE HEEL WORE OUT AND SO DID THE TOE. DO NOT PURCHASE TROTTERS, THEY ARE NOT A "COMFORT" SHOE