Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Collection Baldwin Penny

Perfect

Wear them everyday - super comfortable and look great

Good looking & comfortable!

These shoes are so soft and comfortable, and they look very nice on. They fit true to size as well. I would highly recommend these shoes.

Excellent pair of shoes. The leather is buttery smooth and the color is top tier. Well worth the money and I am already receiving so many compliments. They also seem to magically erase sweat if you decide to rock them barefoot!

Love this shoe. Look is great. Does run a bit on the small side. I purchased an 8 , then exchanged for an 8. 5. Fit is good. Threading on outside of right shoe is a bit loose. Perhaps manufacturing flaw.

Absolutely perfect fit as usual and great quality!

Simply the

The shoes came out very small.

So comfortable and looks good with most outfits.

Great!!!

Way too narrow, but I will try to stretch them out. Why don't these shoes come in a wide width size?

I have been using. Johnston Murphy shoes. For past 15 years. I have seven paires. They are so comfortable. I dnt buy any other shoe. Am a doctor I wear it for work. Almost 12 hrs. I wear.

Beautiful shoe but fits poorly. The toe box is painfully snug. I have bought many size 11M shoes from J&M and they always fit great, but not this pair.

Soft/Comfortable and nice looking!

Both right shoes are too small by the little toe.

This is the best looking and fitting shoe I have ever owned

Some of the best looking shoes out there. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a stylish lofer that youd be able to dress up or down. These are definitely a must have.

I love these shoes, comfortable to walk in, and I like the heel click from the shoes. Makes it feel professional.

My Baldwin Penny loafers are not only stylish but also so comfortable that I can wear them without socks. I bought them in cognac and black. Also, I have a 12 narrow shoe size so it's difficult to find shoes but the Johnston & Murphy medium is a perfect fit. I would highly recommend their shoes for anyone with a narrow foot.

Linda was very helpful in answering my questions on the softness of the tan leather Penny loafers. She suggested leather balm to looking nice. The company answered my many questions and everyone was pleasant and helpful.

Excellent fit, comfort and style

Purchased this sheepakin loafer with a classic style hoping they would be more comfortable than my leather ones. They are very comfortable, but fit true to size but not quite as stylish I'll take the trade off in these less formal times.

A+++

Shoes are really nice but the 12 was too tight at top of foot and the 13 was way too big. There was not a 12 1/2 available or did not come in half sizez. I had to take to a leather store and have them stretch them. 20$.