Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Collection Jameson Wing Tip

I had my eyes on these shoes for a long time before I bought them and they were well worth the wait. Very comfortable and they look really good with any kind of pants - very casual to business casual. I especially like them with jeans and dark pants.

I love the way these look and feel. The leather softens very nicely. Very classy and yet has a casual look too. I've compared many others and these are the best in quality. They are so nice that I own two pairs - black and brown, although I do wish they also came with a traditional heel and sole.

Great looking show.

Great pair of shoes. Went on a family get away and received all kinds of compliments. Great dressy look, but still casual.

Great looking, comfortable shoe. Had to order half size smaller than other J&M shoes I own.

Johnston Murphy shoes are THE best. This pair in the lighter brown is beautiful. Fit is perfect. Shipping outstanding and fast. The best!

Suede is supple and of high quality. A little narrow for my wide feet but suede is usually pretty malleable so the shoe should mold to most feet assuming the length is for correct. Very stylish as well.

Loved the comfort and look of these shoes. Also loved the packaging !!

These shoes are sophisticated and stylish for a true gentlemen.

This shoe is much better quality than shoes I have purchased in the past.

Beautiful she the looks nice in jeans and or dress slacks. Good look!

I had a pair of these that lasted about 5 years and I wore them constantly. Very comfortable, great fit, and a sharp look too.

I really like this shoe! I prefer loafers over laces, but some loafers lack character. Not this suede slip-on wingtip! It adds a classic lace up style to what I think a more modern and dressed down, classic wingtip. The suede adds helps blend a casual style into a classic dress shoe. They run true to size. They are slightly tight in the toe box but will benefit from some stretching and wear. I've only worn them twice and they are already breaking in nicely. The only drawback and the reason for the loss of one star, which otherwise would have been a perfect score, is that the footbeds are not removable. I suffer from planter fasciitis and would prefer to replace the footbed with my own, which adds more arch support.

A little concerned about the soles.

Out of 10 pairs of JM shoes I own, these did not fit true to size and are rather stiff and uncomfortable. Throwing on my Upton was like putting on a sneaker in comparison. They most definitely run a half size too big necessitating a half size down. Even with a double layer insole and a heal protector, the heals still had slippage and my achilles ached for three days. They are, however, beautiful shoes!

Jameson WIngtip dress shoes create a good look and are comfortable for all-day wear.

Good and comfortable shoes overall.

I like everything about these shoes except the soles. They are very similar to a pencil easer and last about as long. I've had this pair about a month or two and is considerable wear on the soles. I will be lucky if I get 6 months of wear out of these before having to resole or trash.

I need a wider width because I have a high instep

i returned them

A bit disappointed. The shoe runs large, and is a bit boxier than I thought it would be. Also the dark brown color is almost black - not a very attractive color. It appears to be easy on the soles for walking, which was the main reason I got it.

I love the way these shoes look and feel, but after wearing them a couple of times, the rubber on the toe starts to fray. These shoes are way too expensive for this to happen. This is really disappointing because the quality of JM shoes are usually top-notch.

First, I was thinking I would be ok with a rubber sole. I was wrong. Second, I wear size 13, but these shoes made my feet look even bigger. Third, the details on the picture were much more detailed than those on the actual shoe.

Great looking upper but soles frayed after 4 times wearing. Need to solve that issue. Will be returning. It's too bad because they look great and comfortable. Just need to resolve to rubber sole used.

EVERY SHOE I OWN IS A JOHNSTON AND MURPHY, AND OVER THE YEARS I'VE NEVER BEEN DISAPPOINTED... UNTIL THIS SHOE. I PURCHASED THESE AND THE UPTON PLAIN TOE WHICH HAS THE SAME TYPE OF SOLE. THE SOLE SHREADS AND PEELS WHICH LOOK DREADFUL FOR A SHOE OF THIS QUALITY. AS MANY TIMES THAT I'VE RECOMMENDED JM, I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND ANY OF THE SHOES THAT HAVE THIS TYPE SOLE.