Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waterproof XC4® XC4 H1-Luxe Hybrid

Good looking but too narrow for my foot. Uncomfortable, but trying to stretch them

They are nice shoes, but the width is narrower than many other brands. That makes an uncomfortably tight fit

Very nice shoes but they caused deep blisters on my heels. Unable to return as they have been worn...

Too narrow even with the intersole out. Pleas make wider shoes.

The toe became undone on both shoes after a few weeks

Just bought these in black and tried them on with no socks. I got a half size bigger and they were very tight and narrow. So bummed and wish their gold shoes came in a side wider. Their dress shoes and comfy loafer style shoes are never an issue for me.

It was the perfect golf shoe for about a month. I play golf as a walker and primarily during the morning dew hours so comfort and waterproof are huge. This shoe met the task for about 8 rounds until the portion of the sole that wraps up around to the toe area started to separate and the shoe was no longer waterproof.

To start, I searched months for the right shoe that fit well and was comfortable and landed on these shoes for the 2022 season. After a few rounds I was hooked on the brand and shoe. To my surprise after just 8 rounds the toe glue started letting lose and the white (main body color) on the front of the shoe started coming off and now looks brown. I've since stopped wearing the shoe which is extremely disappointing being I liked the shoe. For this price I expected much better quality! Needless to say after several attempts to the company directly I have not heard a word! Shame on you for charging this kind of money and having such poor customer service!

The heel on the outer sole is worn & looks over worn after 5 or 6 times

I like the look of the shoes. The fit is OK, but they are difficult to put on given the sock lining design. I do have to apply tape to my heels before playing a round to avoid having blisters and broken skin on my heels - the heel of the shoes bite into my heels. Lastly, after but two rounds, the tops of the shoes are full of stains and dirt. How do you keep these clean? To be candid, I am disappointed in these shoes.

I bought these in the quasi wide width. Be careful as these have a weird built in sock that does not allow your foot to go in comfortably.

Elegant look, yet very delicate and poor material. Mine in few months got serious scratches in different spots

Poor construction. Can't get them on without a lot of effort. Sent them back.

Your golf shoes run very small compared to your normal shoes. Whoever is making them is NOT fitting them to your normal size code.

In a very short time, the black underneath faded through the white portion on the toes of both shoes. VERY DISAPPOINTING!!!

I'm a size 9 in Nike and Cole Haan. I bought these in the white in size 9. I liked it so much I ordered the same ones in black online. I was so excited to get it. But very disappointed! The black on size 9 (I made sure it was men's) was extremely tight! I had to return it. I wish JM could have consistency in their sizings. Very frustrating to buy/return/buy

Fits too tight...not a comfortable fit.

The shoes were too small and narrow.

Too narrow Returned

This shoe was very difficult for me to get my foot into. Very very stiff.

I finally broke down and bought an expensive pair of golf shoes. I have been a Johnston and Murphy customer for a long time. This is the primary brand of shoe I purchase for work and casual wear. When I received the new golf shoes, one of the shoes had a significant defect. The lacing on the tongue was coming apart. By the time I went through the replacement process, and received the new pair, I missed wearing them on the planned golf trip which is really why I bought them in the first place. I believe this defect should have been caught during the QC process. Just giving some feedback with the intent for future QC improvement.

Great look but I immediately had heel blisters on my first few rounds. The inner insole rides up too high and causes blisters. I will never buy J&M golf shoes again.

Disappointing that J&M does not offer a 7 or 7.5. I know that this is not a review of a purchase, but of a manufacturer that does not even offer me a chance to buy any of their shoes. I hoped to join my J&M clothing with the shoes, but they don't make a smaller size.

Loved the look of these shoes when I ordered them. During my first round of golf in Florida after 6 holes I developed painful blisters on my heals. By the way I was riding in a golf cart, therefore not walking a lot. I suffered through the 18 holes in pain. I wore the shoes a week later while still wearing my blister pads on my feet. This was the only way I could wear these shoes. A month after returning from Florida I wore the shoes again without heel bandages and I didn't make the first nine without bloody blisters. I am very disappointed in these shoes. The design is flawed due to the elastic inner boot which allows the heels to move up and down as you walk no matter how tight you tie the laces. I will NEVER BE ABLE TO WEAR THESE SHOES!! BAD DESIGN!!

Insert on sole coming loose-J&M refuses to address the problem