Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy XC4 Tanner Plain Toe

This is my third pair of this same shoe. I have about 7 other pairs of JM shoes. Awesome to say the least.

Need a wide

Did I need a new pair of blue loafers? Probably not, but I got these, and I couldnt be happier. I bought them because they look good and they are waterproof but wearing them is actually the best part because theyre so comfortable. Ive bought a lot of shoes in the last year but Johnston & Murphy are definitely my faves and these are right at the top of the list.

California weather predictions spelled doom for ordinary office footwear. This shoe withstood the torrential rains, keeping my feet dry while looking sharp. I have many J&M shoes and these rate high in comfort.

It has not arrived yet

the shoes looks ok , but the paking and delivery was not so good.

Overall, the shoes are extremely comfortable and great looking. My only complaint is that the side on my right shoe dug into my ankle and caused a blister. I like the shoes enough I just put a bandaid on the area the next time I wore them but that was the first time I have had the problem with shoes in a long time.

Just got these shoes, they are super comfortable fit and great style! But what's up with the laces? They are super twisted and wrinkled up and it doesn't come out. Looks terrible for such a nice and expensive pair of shoes. I tried to get them wet and hang clothes pins to weight them down. Then tried fabric softener and hung the shoes by the laces to weight them down more, neither worked. Finally tried ironing them and that mostly worked. For $200 they should come ready to wear. Would love a reply if there is a simpler solution.

AMAZING! Best dress shoes I've ever owned. EXTREMELY comfortable, more so than any other J&M shoes I've owned. Look Awesome! Lots of compliments. Expensive, but worth every penny!!

Larger than true to size. Wish the gray color came with black bottom.

Larger than true to size. Wish the gray color came with black bottom.

Bought these shoes for my husband , he likes them and says there very comfortable

Laces are too long. Fit is a bit loose. Shouldve found a store or purchased something else.

Nice looking shoe. I buy J&M shoes often and have not had this problem before, but these gave me a bad blister the first time I wore them. Hopefully will not be an issue after breaking int.

Nice looking shoe. I buy JM shoes often and have not had this problem before, but these gave me a bad blister the first time I wore them. Hopefully will not be an issue after breaking int.

Pros: Probably the most comfortably shoe I have used for work. I transitioned from Ecco after using their shoes for many years. Nice looking, good overall quality. Easy to maintain. The leather is very resilient and keeps it good appearance through time. Cons: Some of the sections of the sole started to come loose, I glue one back together, it worked. It had me concerned enough not to buy it again. But I still did, maybe with this feedback it can be improved. With that fixed, it would be 5 Stars.

I love the look and feel of the shoe. I purchased in Jan. 23. 6 months later the sole started making a noise like air coming out when I walked. For the price of these I would have like for them to last longer. Contacted J&M and got no response.

Great looking shoe but only giving 4 stars because I expected that the shoe would be more of a walking shoe. They are very rigid and provide great support all around but heavy and go a little high up to the ankle bone causing some irritation at that point. Perhaps they run about half a size too big.

This is my second pair of this shoe. The originals wouldve lasted longer but the dog chewed them.

This is my 2nd pair of Tanners. I bought these for work. They are the most comfortable shoe Ive worn. I even want to wear them outside of workthey are that good.

Good looking shoe that can go casual or "more" dressed up. Unfortunately for me, the M/W sizing does not work. Wide is not wide. And pulling out the insole to make these "wide", just removes some of the padding. If you have a narrow foot, you will love these shoes. If you have a wide foot, I recommend a different shoe.

Good looking shoe that can go casual or "more" dressed up. Unfortunately for me, the M/W sizing does not work. Wide is not wide. And pulling out the insole to make these "wide", just removes some of the padding. If you have a narrow foot, you will love these shoes. If you have a wide foot, I recommend a different shoe.

Break in is hard. I've had for two weeks and the heal is still very still. I love J&M shoes and think they will break with wear.

Break in is hard. I've had for two weeks and the heal is still very still. I love J&M shoes and think they will break with wear.

This was the only pair of 5 that I tried that lived up to the wide fit. I like that it is waterproof as well and is comfortable -- still new so a little stiff but I expect that to change.