Customer Reviews Madewell The Cady Lugsole Sandal

The style of these are adorable, but the metal piece on the toe strap rubbed my foot so badly. I stretched them out with big socks and a blow dryer and that did help some. I have slightly wide feet and a small bunion, but shoes don't normally bother me- the metal piece on these was really annoying, especially for the price.

If you have wide feet these are sadly not for you- I have a hammer toe and sadly it makes my feet too wide to fit this beautiful sandal. Had to return

I love the style, but darn-it-all, it's too narrow :(

These are really cute sandals. However, they run a bit narrow. You can dress them up or down as they are very stylish. I'm happy I made the purchase.

The decorative metal parts on the front of the sandal were immediately uncomfortable. Cute, but not going to work.

I was excited to get these sandals, only to be disappointed in the color, the fit, and the ‘leather’ uppers. So happy ZAPPOS has their 365/returns! Back to shopping!

Runs a bit narrow at the toe. However, biggest frustration was that these were clearly worn/used! Holes stretched out from someone buckling them and scuffs all over the footbed. Too expensive to keep used shoes. Unfortunately, it was a return for me.

The front strap was too tight and made the sandal uncomfortable

These are the most disappointing shoes I think I've ever purchased. The metal buckles across the toe are not something that "break in". They hurt, every time I wear them. Miserable.