Customer Reviews Kate Spade New York Treasure Trove Studs Earrings

When the earring came in the were much smaller than I had expected. I really wish that they were bigger

I wore these earrings once and the back of one of them completely came off and broke. I am a loyal Kate Spade customer and have never had a problem with any of their products before. I am very disappointed in the craftmanship of this piece Kate Spade!

They looked beautiful from the photos but in person, they are heavy and very sparkly, and not appropriate for daily wear to work. That was my goal, but these are definitely for special occasions only.

The 'needle' of the studs is really short. I lost one stud on my first day wear them.

bought this online so didn't get to see this in person. i'm glad i bought it on sale because in person the green part looks pretty cheap! If i could, I would return this item.

These earrings are perfect!

I received in the mail looks nothing like the description of the earrings

Bought these earlier and the backing is so loose that it falls off.

Haven't received

Broken from the back side of the studs. Did not take any care when packed to ship them. Very dissatisfied .

I absolutely loved these earrings until after I only wore them twice the back post broke off of one and I lost it. I would love to have this replaced.

1 Stars

Just ugly. Not what was on the picture. Purchases 3 pairs and they are final sale. Fail!

Very cute earrings. Unacceptable packaging. Both earring posts arrived bent.

Earrings are beautiful!!! Backings terrible and lost one earring the first time I wore them. So disappointed and now they are out of stock. Use sturdier backings if you purchased these.

They came tarnished. Not at all pretty or capable of wearing. Super disappointed.

HUGE in size, not at all realistic. Also, there's a "film" on the stones, looks like dried soap bubbles or something. VERY disappointed!

the back part keeps on falling off... almost lost an earring twice. Poor Quality! I am so disappointed.

The back pole broke off these earrings the second time I wore them. I was really disappointed, as they are beautiful. But I feel my money was completely wasted.

Earrings were cheap, and one broke my first time wearing it.

The packaging was so flimsy that the posts were bent when they arrived

I thought they would be smaller. They take up practically your entire earlobe. Makes them look cheap, unfortunately.

Way too Big!! These are so huge they make my ears look like new born baby ears!!

I did not like the appearance of the stone. The cuts in the stone make it look like there are several black spots on them. Very disappointed that I can't even return them. I purchased them for a gift and won't even give them out due to their appearance.

They arrived broken and we're sold out by the time they arrived so couldn't be replaced. They're a perfect size, just unwearable in their current state. The first customer service person I talked to told me he could refund me 15% which ended up being about $2 or making a trip to the post office to get a full refund. I told him I would think about it, and when I talked to the next person she was wonderful and just refunded me the money without making me go through the hassle of going to the post office to ship them back.