Customer Reviews Kate Spade New York Treasure Trove Studs Earrings

I didn't think these were so large. I love them for myself, but intended them to be for my mom and they are too big.

I have been an admirer of Kate Spade for many years, and I like to treat myself on occasion. These earrings have such a great look and I have received many compliments. However, there are two issues that I really have. 1) The posts are not in fact gold filled as stated in the description. The posts are a generic costume jewelry post, and are a different material from the the gold plated bow which was very disappointing. 2) This might seem silly, but there is no maker's mark anywhere on the product. I wouldn't generally spend this much on a pair of consume jewelry earrings, but I believe in the level of quality of this company. But when a company like Kate Spade doesn't place a maker's mark on their product it makes me feel like it isn't a product they care about, or are proud of and makes me feel like I got a cheap product which also really disappoints me.

They looked cute in the photo, but up close it is quite hard to tell they are bows. They are quite large which I expected from the photo, however, my ear lobes are too petite for me to pull these off. I wish they weren't as clunky.

The backs don't stay on very well so it is easy to lose them!

These earrings are really cute but they are Neon Orange Popsicles and I was disappointed because I really wanted Pink Popsicle earrings, as they were advertised to be..

maybe i have fat earlobes, but these earrings are too tight.

I ORDERED THESE EARRINGS ONLINE AND WAS EXCITED TO RECEIVE THEM BUT WAS DISAPPOINTED AFTER I TRIED THEM ON. IT'S A CUTE DESIGN, SEEMINGLY GOOD QUALITY, BUT JUST TOO BIG. THEY ARE TOO FLASHY FOR STUDS AND NOT AT ALL SUBTLE, ESPECIALLY FOR BRIDAL JEWELRY. I WISH THERE HAD BEEN A PICTURE OF THE EARRINGS ON A MODEL OR SOME ADDITIONAL SIZE INFORMATION BECAUSE I COULDN'T GET A GOOD SENSE OF THIS BEFORE PURCHASING. I SINCE CAME ACROSS A PHOTO OF THEM ON A MODEL ON NORDSTROM'S SITE, SO RECOMMEND CHECKING THAT OUT IF YOU'RE CURIOUS. UNFORTUNATELY THEY ARE GOING BACK AND MY SEARCH FOR BRIDAL STUDS CONTINUES...

Lost one on first wear backing did not hold bummed

They are really cute, but I am sensitive and they make my ears itch after wearing for the day.

The stem on one of the earrings was bent upon arrival. These are larger than they look in the photos.

Cute studs but the backs do not stay on for anythingalready almost lost the earrings multiple times because of it. Quality was not what I would have expected.. Will not be surprised when I lose them because of it. Buying replacement backs off of Amazon immediately

I need to say I thought these were kind of tacky

Too tiny and the picture didn't project that

These earrings are super tiny!

I ordered these earrings thinking they were a bit smaller. They look too big on me, I can't even wear earrings on my second piercing because they are in the way. Wouldn't recommend if you have multiple piercings and typically wear earrings in each one.

I purchased these earrings on clearance and got what I paid for. I was surprised that they were larger than I expected, but that wasn't necessarily a good thing as I prefer a more dainty earring. I also expected the stones to be pink, however only the metal was pink. The stones were clear except for the dark inclusions which were very visible. I was not expecting a quality stone and would not have been disappointed if they had been the color I was expecting.

The earrings are extremely heavy, beautiful but heavy.

I bought 2 of these as gifts and I am really disappointed. They look like they are poor quality. They have dark colored speckles in them and the color is off. They are also much larger than I expected. Unfortunately I cannot return them but I will not be gifting them to anyone.

2 Star

Really pretty but huge! They will look nice for a fancy outfit-but not daily use

Extremely large button earrings!

Pretty, but looks cheap. They had no ''shimmer'' like true opals would have. This might as well have been dropshipped off Wish because that's how cheap they looked. Also the packaging.... I received a large box with a lot of packing paper in it for a tiny pair of earrings. What I don't understand is why the earrings were not covered with the packing paper to be protected. Instead, they were on top of it, completely left unprotected during shipping. Overall I'm not impressed.

The earrings are slightly different in size! The photo online shows them to be identical, but one is actually a little smaller than the other.

I am not particularly happy with this purchase. The scale is too large and they look cheap.

Too big for my taste