Customer Reviews PIKOLINOS Aldaya W8J-3541

These shoes are ready to wear out of the box. Smart looking style, great color, true fit, they are just right!

If this shoe didn’t have such a narrow toe box I’d give it 5 stars. Nice updated classic style, good looking block heel, and the very soft subtle leather make this shoe a winner…except for the narrow toe. Bummer.

The shoes are beautiful, just a little tight for me.

This shoe is very comfortable. I'm sure it would be ready for walking miles without break-in time. I own a couple of other pairs of Pikolinos and the quality and comfort are great. They do tend to fit a narrower foot, so I'm not sure if they'd work for wider feet. This is a very classic penny loafer.

I love my Pikolinos sandals and really wanted these shoes. The shoe was almost too narrow in the ball of the foot yet the heel was so wide I had trouble keeping the shoe on when I walked. I don't understand why slip on shoes have such wide heels.

What beautiful shoes! Soft leather, stylish and very well made. Regretfully they were too narrow; I have a high instep and could not get my foot completely into the shoe.

I have this same loafer from Pikolinos in a different color. These fit smaller although they do stretch out. Overall I wasn't happy with the finishing on the leather - the two shoes looked different and for this price that isn't acceptable. Also the packaging was horrible. One small sheet of thin paper in the box - not even wrapped around the shoe. The came via Amazon delivery like most of my recent Zappos purchases.

I love Pikolinos leather- so buttery soft. And the styles are gorgeous. These shoes are snug if you have wide feet. I run into problems mostly with the vamp of the shoe being too tight. Which it is, but this type of leather will stretch a bit and I’m taking a chance they will work in time. I really struggle with finding the right dress shoe to fit my feet.

I really wanted to love this shoe. I like the way it looks but the toe is too narrow and my foot felt squeezed. I bought these for walking, so I knew they wouldn't work.

The 6.5-7.0 fits like a 6.5. It is too short for a true 7.

These are beautiful shoes but on me they were both a little tight across the ball of my foot and too loose in the heel. I'm sad to have to send them back.

This is a beautiful, classic penny loafer in a gorgeous color. Unfortunately, the toe box was too narrow for my feet and the shoe was too shallow for my orthotics.

I've always loved my Pikolinos shoes! I ordered the same size I always wear with this brand, 40, and the Aldayas we too small. :( Definitely order a size up with this loafer.

I loved the style, quality and comfort of the shoe but the toe box was just too narrow for my foot. Sadly I am returning the shoes.

They look like they’ve been worn already. I wear and 8 and they are definitely a 7 1/2.

Beautiful shoe and very well made but the fit was awful for me. I’m pretty much always a size 10 (M), so I ordered EU 41 (US Women’s 10.5-11) B (M). I could barely get them on because they were so narrow and tight across the top of my foot. Definitely didn’t fit like size 10.5-11 (M). I would say fit more like size 10 Narrow. Unfortunately, I had to return them.

The fit on these shoes is really mislabeled. They are much smaller that other EU size 42 shoes.

These are so beautiful, and I normally love Pikolinos shoes, but these were half a size too small.

These are attractive well made shoes. I wear a size 8 and these were uncomfortably tight. I retuned them for a size bigger.