Customer Reviews ECCO Modtray Penny Loafers

I wore these right out of the box. Not too heavy. I’m at 10.5 and the size 41 is good. Very stylish.

These shoes are well made, beautiful, and comfortable! It’s rare for me to find anything comfortable to wear except running shoes. I need a lot of support for my old broke feet (fallen arches, bunion, hammer toes) and these do the trick. I love the look and don’t mind the white piece on the inside at all—I think it looks cool :)

I have tried just about every 15 different loafers to find one that is comfortable after having foot surgery. These are perfect, stylist, comfortable and holds my foot perfectly. Great for walking.

They are narrow which works for me. Today is the first time I have worn them and they are rubbing on my heal but I hope after being broke in they will be perfect! I love they way they look.

Loved these right out of the box! I am a 10 in athletic shoes and a 9.5 or sometimes a 9 in dress shoes. I ordered the 9-9.5 (40). Cute and comfortable, no break-in time required. I would have rated at 5 stars, but I do have a little bit of heel slippage and that can be expected with loafers. Also- even tho these have a chunky sole, they don't feel heavy at all. Although the modtray is white on these, it's really not that noticeable and it provides great support for those of us that need a little extra. Give them a try!

These fit well, but they are quite narrow. My feet are a 7.5 (R) and an 8 (L) so the 38s in Ecco tend to work for me. I only wish the toe box was wider, but I will stretch it out a bit. These have the best arch support of any loafers I've tried. (I have medium-high arches.)They look cute with jeans or dressier outfits. I bought the black, and the white "tray" under the arch is a bit annoying aesthetically - out of the corner of my eye, it can look like I have something stuck to my shoe. Still - I love these and am keeping. They do need a little breaking in.

Very comfortable, good arch support, but they slip in the heel.

I love these shoes, but I wish I'd ordered a half size smaller. I have narrow feet and these are amazing in width, with good quality leather - which is naturally very snug with a new pair of shoes. Because of this (good thing), I didn't realize that the shoes were actually a bit too long. So my foot slides a bit. *However,* as I wear them and break them in, my foot is moving in them a bit less. My heel still slips a bit and I have some socks I can't wear with them b/c they slide down as I walk. Normally I wear an 8.5 - 9 US, and I ordered the 8-8.5 US. If not for the slight aggravation with fit, I'd be thrilled with these shoes. As it is, I just really like them.

Fit is pretty good. They look good. I'm happy with them.

The length and width are perfect but the arch support is not lined up with my arch so the footbed doesn't feel right. Also, I don't care for the white detail on the sole.

Cute but did not work for me. My foot is a 10.5 and between a B-C width. I ordered these in an 11B (which sometimes works) but they were too tight on my foot.

Too bad! It was a structured, supportive loafer but way too narrow. My toes need room. Back it goes!

This shoe fit but felt very stiff. Also, looked masculine. Plus was good support.

Was narrow shoe

May have been a woman's size

Different shoes from what I ordered were delivered

This shoe is way too narrow