Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Islander

They're good looking and will be potentially good for my feet but need a tremendous amount of breaking in. I'm grateful they haven't cut my feet like other styles and I keep coming back to Dr. Scholl's for style and the need for support. I keep trying!

Cute and comfortable! The strap closest to the toes does not have give to it and is slightly tighter than I like (which makes it a 4/5 for me). I don't think I could wear them all day walking around on vacation, however for typical outings they work well. Much more comfortable than my other flat sandals.

I usually wear a 7.5, but friend who had purchased said they ran big, so I bought 7

Super comfortable sandals. The front is leather so my blister sisters beware, but it didn't cause me any issues like I was expecting it too. The arch is very prominent which feels nice and supportive, but I ordered my normal size and they do feel a bit long. If I get my foot in the right place they're okay, but every now and then I was tripping over the toe.

The edges of the soles had these small bumps which made it feel like I had small rocks underneath my feet and caused some irritation. I had to take a nail file to them and they were fine. Just do a quick inspection before wearing them out for the day

I bought these this past weekend and have worn them twice. They felt comfortable and I was excited to wear them to work. Well, today (only the second time wearing them) I came home and noticed that part of the heel (The wrap around wood looking strap) is peeling off! I'm very annoyed because these were not cheap sandals to be breaking after the second wear! I've always had good luck with Sketchers, so maybe I'll need to go back to that brand.

Cute shoes but the elastic stretched out pretty quickly and the front strap across my toes rubs.

I loved the sandals, and was disappointed that I had to send them back. I ordered my normal size 7m, but they were too wide. The length of the shoe was fine, but the width was not. My foot wasn't secure in the sandal. If the elastic would stretch with wearing, my foot would of slid all over the place.

Decent Shoe. Wish the upper strap was around the ankle and not the foot. I feel like this would provide me with more support while walking. Also wish the lower strap was thinner so would rub on my toes less as I walk. Also there is a slight heel. I'm hoping this will flatten out as I break them in. Also size down. When determining my size they recommend a half size larger for me. Size down a half size.

Footbed not firm enough for my needs, straps are very comfortable. Cute shoe but just need firmer foot bed for long day comfort.

Looking for a comfy Sandell to wear on a vacation. Not as attractive as in photo