Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Amherst Knit U Throat

These were a gift to my husband. He loved them and thought they were really great looking, super casual, classy sneakers that would be very comfy. They get 4 stars instead of 5 because these shoes initially gave him a blister on the back of his heel. Once they were broken in, they were fine.

Great look and for the most part very comfortable, however when walking any significant distance blisters occur.

Love the look and style. I would like a little more room in the toe box especially. They likely will expand some with additional wear. They are very comfortable and light, while giving good support and bounce when moving.

Overall well fitting shoe, could use a little better insole to increase comfort for longer periods of time on feet or longer distance walks.

Nice, casual, comfortable.

Love this shoe but the missing color on the front faded after a few months and are eye sores. Really good fitting shoe though. Would wear without socks.

I purchased these for my son who wears a size 14. Was told that the 13 would be fine as they ran big and they were except his heel slides out of the back which causes blisters.

Only complaint is after about half a day of wearing, a crease forms across the top of both shoes which limits the time I can wear them.

I liked the style and the comfort level was right on. The only negative was that the added strip of color around the top edge of the sole started flaking off with in a week or two. Would buy again if the strip of color was part of the material and not an added top coat.

The shoes are are excellent style style and are comfortable at 1st.However, they are not that great for an all day shoe where you are on your feet for at least half of the day. The holes in the bottom of the shoe will allow water loud water to creep in if you step in-and-in the kind of small puddles when it is raining.

Comfy, but leather seems thin

Bought the Amherst and the Jogger. Loved the Jogger for comfort, style and stability. The Amherst has great style and comfort but substantially less stability. It's a good shoebut wish I had bought a second Jogger color instead.

This is a good looking shoe that is comfortable. I have received positive comments about them.

Great fit,very comfortable

These shoes run larger than what you would normally. Had to return for 1/2 size smaller. On the plus size they are comfortable when you get your correct fit,

I ordered these online for my husband and accidentally ordered the wrong size. I exchanged them in store and it was very quick and easy. Good looking shoe however not a walking shoe, even though it looks like a sneaker. He wears them for looks, but needs more support for long walks.

lightweight. somewhat stylish

I liked the look of the shoe but the color was more teal than blue in real life so it was a no go for me. A shame as I liked the shoe otherwise.

great style great comfort. light gray gets dirty easily . how do you clean them. Can you throw them in the wash?

The knit uppers provide comfort and less weight which makes for easy walking. I like the style and look. My only concern is how to keep the shoe looking good (clean) over time. No care instructions were provided.

Looks great. Feels comfortable but after 6hrs, the top of my feet hurt.. so don't think I'm lacing them too tight

I like the look and style of this shoe. It is very comfortable but I wish it had a little more support.

Shoe looks great and is comfortable with the knit upper. I normally wear a 14 and ordered the 14 - the length is perfect, but I wish the toe box was more rounded and wider on the outside of the foot - the pointy slope is too snug against the outer toes.

They look amazing. I love everything about the look. The heel rubs a little on the back and where it creases on the toe it just feels "funny" not sure how else to describe. Want them to make a 2.0 model to fix a couple things!

These shoes are very comfortable and look sharp. They do feel on the big side to me, definitely in width. I have several J&M shoes and wear a 10.5 every time but this one seems to have room to spare. The sole feels like a pair or Crocs, which, though comfortable, certainly makes me question the price point of these shoes and wonder how long they'll last.