Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey Slip-On

Comfortable, I like the way it feels. Gets dirty a little easy so I have to be careful. Overall love it, going to buy the blue one.

Nice looking shoe, but too long! The shoe was comfortable in my size, but the elongated look of the extra 1-1/4" of the shoe was not appealing to my eye.

These McGuffey slip-ons have the most comfortable fit and the best cushioning among all the J&M shoes I've purchased over the years. My only gripe is that the shoe could have been made with slightly thicker leather and the leather lining could have been more extensive. Hence, the 4* instead of 5*.

Love the style. Only thing is the heal could be firmer as the heal collapses when I try to just step into the shoe.

Returned for a smaller size, have not heard back.

the shoe is fine however the color seem to be a little off black instead of black other than that it is comfortable it fits good I normally wear a 10 and this is a 10 and a half and it fits very well

Quality was good but too wide and big. Returned for another style that fits perfectly

Comfortable, stylish slip os

Great, but stretches

It's a great shoe. I thought it would be a little lighter than what it is. Other than that, its prefect

Johnston & Murphy always carry a different price range of shoes that meet your need for different occasions, with quality craftsmanship. I would recommend to all of my friends & family.

Not as comfortable as I would expect , the XC4 brand are much more comfortable, Yet this is a very good footwear for the regular guy without back or knee problem like me.

I absolutely love the shoes but they do run a bit large. I wear a size 9 normally. I should have ordered an 81/2. Not the end of the world. Thicker socks.

Light weight shoe that you can dress up or down.

Like the style and very comfortable.

I need to be careful to keep them clean. I am uncertain how to clean them.

Nice looking shoes to wear with shorts

Comfortable shoe. Fits true to size. Would prefer darker color (whole shoe in same darker shade that is in front of shoe.

Really love the style and support in this shoe. I bought them as a summer casual shoe to where with shorts (without socks). I found that they are equally good with slacks for a dressy casual evening out. One issue--the cushion insole inside the shoe sticks to the bottom of my foot (when I wear no socks) and pulls out of the shoe when I take them off.

Overall this shoe is comfortable and can be worn as either a relaxed shoe with shorts or as a dress shoe with the right pants. I enjoy it and will likely get a second pare or a different color. Now for the reason I give it 4 stars instead of 5. While they can be worn without socks, one day while walking without Sox they rubbed both my heals raw. One to a point where it was lightly bleeding. With socks: never a problem. Without socks: my heals will get sore after a while. Interestingly, the shoes fit great, it's just the lip of the material at the heal that causes it. But the shoe is so versatile I just don't care. If I am going to walk long distances I wear something else. For a casual/typical day? These are a go to shoe in my wardrobe.

Returned the size 10 I ordered and waiting for Delivery of the size 9.5

Very comfortable shoe

I love the McGuffey slip-on series of shoes. I think this is my 6th pair. All in different colors and textures. Great fit and very comfortable. The only draw back is that the soles wear out too quickly and they can't be fixed by the shoe repair man.

I like them , I have wide foot but they are breaking in well

Great causal shoe